The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Chris McMonigle is narrowing names down for his upcoming Yankee Podcast, Hoff is narrowing his wiggle room to flying to and back from Florida in time for Mondays show. Carton takes revenge on both!

Some people may think that the Jets have so many choices at quarterback. The real question is, what's the best option? The comparison turns into a Titanic reference which leads into C-Mac's hate for the movie, or the boat, or both!

Juan Soto is having a blast at the WBC and the games don't even count yet. Plus, Shohei is the best of the best in all of sports.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the hottest sports topics you NEED to know! From Juan Soto’s surprising preference for the Dominican Republic over the Mets, to his massive $765M contract and potential opt-out drama, we cover it all. Plus, the Carton crew hilariously dissects LeBron James’ most ridiculous flop ever, debates the most watchable MLB stars like Aaron Judge and Shohei Ohtani, and dives into Mickey Mantle’s career and recovery struggles.

Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle break down the shocking news: the highly anticipated Fanatics Flag Football event with Tom Brady, Saquon Barkley, Max Crosby, and Gronk is moving from Saudi Arabia to Los Angeles! What does this mean for player pay and taxes? Will Tom really be making $50 million?

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the Giants’ latest shocking moves in the running back room! Is Singletary’s contract restructure a sign they’re NOT going after Kenneth Walker? Could the Giants be ignoring the top RB market completely? Plus, jaw-dropping stories from deer in backyards, ATVs, insane fan reactions to Shohei Ohtani, and a wild Miami WNBA moment you won’t believe!

On today’s explosive segment of the Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the latest chaos in the NFL and podcast world! From firing threats and producer drama to Yankees podcast ownership disputes, nothing is off-limits. Plus, a deep dive into the New York Jets quarterback situation: Ty Simpson, Malik Willis, and why some big-money moves just won’t work.

Things got tense (and hilarious) on The Carton Show when Craig Carton laid down the law for producer Pete before his trip to Florida to help produce Evan Roberts’ podcast Rico Brogna.

Things got heated FAST on The Carton Show on WFAN when a caller suggested a shocking quarterback move for the New York Jets and Craig Carton was NOT having it.

The Carton Show on WFAN kicked off with Craig Carton going absolutely nuclear over rumors the New York Jets could bring in Carson Wentz.

The Knicks just miss out on beating a top team in the NBA, but there is no doubt in Craigs mind that the Knicks can hang. Plus, Let's name that number and A millionaire idea! After a long conversation about the worse possible way to die, which is clearly on the toilet, we explore the Mount Rushmore of Dicks! It's now back to back days where Ryan McMahon is getting the start at shortstop. Is this just for fun? And why is Alex Rodriguez at the White House? And why is he such a bad tipper? After a long debate over Saving Silverman and Big Lebowski on whether or not the films are overrated, Craig and Big Mac find out that the Dolphins are looking to trade Tua AND a 1st round pick! Should the Jets think about this trade?

The Knicks just miss out on beating a top team in the NBA, but there is no doubt in Craigs mind that the Knicks can hang. Plus, Let's name that number and A millionaire idea!

After a long conversation about the worse possible way to die, which is clearly on the toilet, we explore the Mount Rushmore of Dicks!

It's now back to back days where Ryan McMahon is getting the start at shortstop. Is this just for fun? And why is Alex Rodriguez at the White House? And why is he such a bad tipper?

After a long debate over Saving Silverman and Big Lebowski on whether or not the films are overrated, Craig and Big Mac find out that the Dolphins are looking to trade Tua AND a 1st round pick! Should the Jets think about this trade?

On this wild segment of the Carton Show on WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into everything Yankees

The Carton Show dives into the wildest sports and pop culture takes yet! From Bob Costas hilariously referencing “two dicks” on NBC, to ranking the ultimate Dick Mount Rushmore including Dick Van Dyke, Dick Clark, Dick Butkus, and more. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle leave no stone unturned. Plus, jaw-dropping stories about Dick Vitale, iconic NBA nostalgia, and some movie references you won’t believe. This is radio chaos you NEED to hear!

The Carton Show goes OFF THE RAILS! From bizarre movie takes, crazy family stories, to Eileen sharing her unforgettable Yankee crush moments. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle keep the laughs and jaw-dropping tales coming. Hear about car crashes, Neil Diamond V.D. jokes, Braille watches, and why Ron Guidry earned the nickname Louisiana Lightning. Don’t miss this unforgettable segment!

This episode is packed with laughs, jaw-dropping facts, and football, baseball hot takes you won’t want to miss!

Things got hilarious on The Carton Show on WFAN as Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle got into a wild debate about why American baseball fans are so BORING compared to the Dominican Republic and international crowds.

The New York Giants offseason debate is heating up on The Carton Show on WFAN as Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle go head-to-head over a shocking idea… Should the Giants sign Stefon Diggs?

Things got hilarious on The Carton Show on WFAN as Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle went head-to-head in a rapid-fire sports trivia game called “Numbers on Numbers.”

The Carton Show on WFAN kicks off with a huge sports debate as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the New York Knicks’ tough loss to the Oklahoma City Thunder and what it actually says about their championship chances.

Craig begs for the Jets to make sure they don't do the dumb thing and bring in Tua Tagovailoa. Plus, how is it possible that a exhibition in the WBC brings more excitement than a regular season baseball game? It sounds impossible, but there is a slight chance that the Giants can shed enough Salary to get close to $100 Million dollars in salary cap. Plus, Craig and C-Mac rank the levels of dumb, and why Juan Soto seems more motivated playing in the WBC. Yaron sits down with Craig and C-Mac to talk about his latest book A Hollywood Ending: The Dreams and Drama of the LeBron Lakers. The news breaks during the show that legendary coach Lou Holtz has died at the age of 89.

Craig begs for the Jets to make sure they don't do the dumb thing and bring in Tua Tagovailoa. Plus, how is it possible that a exhibition in the WBC brings more excitement than a regular season baseball game?

It sounds impossible, but there is a slight chance that the Giants can shed enough Salary to get close to $100 Million dollars in salary cap. Plus, Craig and C-Mac rank the levels of dumb, and why Juan Soto seems more motivated playing in the WBC.

Yaron sits down with Craig and C-Mac to talk about his latest book A Hollywood Ending: The Dreams and Drama of the LeBron Lakers

The news breaks during the show that legendary coach Lou Holtz has died at the age of 89.

Things got HEATED on The Carton Show on WFAN as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate the latest quarterback rumors around the New York Jets.

Craig Carton and "Big Mac" break down the New York Knicks' defensive surge under Mike Brown and debate whether the narrative surrounding former coach Tom Thibodeau holds up to the numbers. Plus, the crew dives into the New York Giants' failed pursuit of Trent McDuffie and a heated debate over the #5 overall pick.

Author Yaron Weitzman joins Craig Carton and the crew on WFAN’s The Carton Show to discuss his explosive new book, “A Hollywood Ending: The Dreams and Drama of the LeBron Lakers.” In this candid interview, Weitzman pulls back the curtain on the "Buss show" dysfunction, the real power dynamics between Klutch Sports and the Lakers front office, and why the LeBron-AD era is being viewed as an "abject failure" by some critics.

Chris McMonigle & Craig Carton dive deep into David Fizdale’s jaw-dropping Knicks revelation, the team allegedly tanked to land Kevin Durant, Kyrie Irving, and even Zion Williamson! Did it all go wrong? Plus, they cover Yankees hot streaks, legendary stadium food, the World Baseball Classic, and the funniest podcast name debates. You don’t want to miss this chaos!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go OFF debating whether America is doing baseball all wrong after seeing the wild celebration for Juan Soto’s exhibition homer in the Dominican! Are we too uptight at games? Should MLB be more like the Savannah Bananas? Or is Chris right to defend pure baseball tradition?

Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle break down the shocking Giants offseason moves, cap space chaos, and how close they came to landing Trent McDuffie! Plus, hilarious “Hammerhead vs. Simple-Minded” debate, forearm shaving drama, and Jets/Yankees hot takes. You won’t believe what went down live in the studio!

Did the New York Giants almost land Trent McDuffie before he was dealt to the Los Angeles Rams?!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go OFF on the latest quarterback rumors linking Tua Tagovailoa to the New York Jets and Craig makes it VERY clear: “I don’t want him.” Plus, a MASSIVE draft debate for the New York Giants. Would you trade the 5th overall pick for #9 and #29? Is it smart business or a HUGE mistake?

While Aaron Judge may be a great player, he is not a great motivator. Plus the Jets start to make some tough decisions! Craig is feeling optimistic by the New York Jets for the first time in a long time. Plus, Alex Rodriguez will never be CC Sabathia. Margot Robbie proves that acting is not a job you can have a long lasting relationship with! Team Italy is stacking up their coaching staff, Hoff get's pranked again and hanging with Danny DeVito!

While Aaron Judge may be a great player, he is not a great motivator. Plus the Jets start to make some tough decisions!

Craig is feeling optimistic by the New York Jets for the first time in a long time. Plus, Alex Rodriguez will never be CC Sabathia.

Margot Robbie proves that acting is not a job you can have a long lasting relationship with!

Team Italy is stacking up their coaching staff, Hoff get's pranked again and hanging with Danny DeVito!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go wild on the air in this unforgettable segment of the Carton Show! From Knicks betting advice (“stay away tonight!”) to a jaw-dropping prank call claiming to be Angelina Jolie’s love child, you won’t believe what happens next. Plus, music history, Michael Jackson vs. Beatles catalog drama, and unbelievable fan stories. This is one WFAN segment you can’t miss!

The Carton Show goes OFF on March 3, 2026! Chris McMonigle & Craig Carton dive into Mets batting practice updates, Nolan McLean’s ear infection, and WBC pitcher drama. Plus, they debate Jorge Posada & Francisco Cervelli’s Team Italy roles, share hilarious Yankees fan stories, talk LeBron James controversy, and even reveal Big Mac’s high school sports secrets. Don’t miss the laughs, inside baseball takes, and wild sports gossip you won’t hear anywhere else!

You won’t believe what went down on the Carton Show today! Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down Russell Wilson’s feud with Sean Payton, Aaron Judge’s playoff struggles, and the shocking JT Miller injury/party controversy. Plus, Jets draft trade talk, Mets & Yankees updates, and some hilarious behind-the-scenes radio stories you won’t hear anywhere else! Don’t miss this chaotic, no-holds-barred WFAN segment.

hris McMonigle & Craig Carton dive into the wildest pop culture and NFL takes on the March 3, 2026 Carton Show! From the mysterious wife of Aaron Rodgers to Shaq’s outrageous new candy, Hollywood scandals with Margot Robbie, and the latest on Kyler Murray’s potential Jets move you won’t believe what they unpacked on-air. Don’t miss the chaos, the laughs, and insider insights!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the heated debate: Should Alex Rodriguez have his number retired by the New York Yankees?

It’s an ALL-OUT QB WAR on The Carton Show! Craig Carton is seeing “sunshine through the clouds” for the New York Jets thanks to Darren Mougey… but Chris McMonigle is NOT buying it. Is Aaron Glenn’s “superpower” just calling defense? Should Frank Reich run the entire offense? And who SHOULD be the Jets’ QB — Kirk Cousins? Anthony Richardson? A rookie like Ty Simpson?

Craig Carton drops a bombshell on the Carton Show, he flat-out says he doesn’t care about Team USA in the World Baseball Classic!

Craig Carton goes OFF on Aaron Judge after his underwhelming Team USA speech ahead of the World Baseball Classic calling it the worst captain’s speech in sports history! Is Judge a great player but a bad leader? And does this explain the New York Yankees October struggles?

Well, a lot of people put money on the Iran supreme leader. And a lot of people won. Unfortunately, all bets were canceled. We find out from the extremely stable Shia Labeouf that Mike Piazza was not very good with the autographs. Plus, the Giants are hunting for a new running back. It's another episode of "Spin That Wheel". They play two rounds. Big Mac vs Hoff and Gallo vs Big Mac. This game is one that will make you yell and scream at the radio. Mike Piazza stories flow in as we find out not signing autographs is part of Mike's norm. Plus, the biggest unknown in the 2026 MLB season is the New York Mets.