The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

On this wild Monday edition of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle go OFF on the sudden surge of St John’s fans after their Sweet 16 run. Are New Yorkers truly back on board, or is this just a city full of bandwagon jumpers? And the guys dive into the Cam Scott controversy, asking the big question: are we taking athletes too seriously or not seriously enough?

Hear from the best guests on WFAN this week, including Howie Rose, Lil’ Wayne, Chris Christie, and Hofstra head coach Speedy Claxton.

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber recall some of Howie Rose’s greatest calls from his illustrious career as he enters his final season calling radio games for the Mets. Plus, Howie joins Evan & Tiki about his decision to retire and talks Mets (12:08); Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss the legacy of Howie Rose (40:54); Craig and C-Mac discuss Nolan McLean pitching in the WBC Final and if the tournament has any impact on legacy (54:00)

Chris McMonigle sounds off on a Red Sox minor leaguer bunting off Gerrit Cole in his first start since Tommy John surgery. Plus, why Evan Roberts finds the bunt ‘controversy’ ridiculous (19:20); Tiki Barber finds out how CC Sabathia feels about the bunt (37:39); Craig Carton and C-Mac debate if Derek Jeter took a subtle dig at Aaron Judge’s World Baseball Classic atmosphere comments (45:26); Boomer & Gio on Judge’s no-win situation in the WBC (56:01)

Jeremiyah Love is all the talk this week, with Evan and Tiki debating with Morash why it would make sense for the Giants to take the running back at No. 5 overall in the upcoming NFL Draft. Plus, Boomer and Gio discuss how the Giants and Jets are heading in different directions with their offseasons.

This week's Jets highlights include Boomer Esiason's confidence that Frank Reich will have a plan for Geno Smith, while Evan and Tiki debate if such a plan will make a difference in the team's QB outlook moving forward. Plus, are the rival Dolphins in full tank mode, and Boomer and Gio break down the different directions that the Jets and Giants seem to be heading.

Jameis Winston has been announced to be part of opening day on Netflix. Carton is not a fan of the idea! Abdul Carter goes full Kobe Bryant and changes his number after one season That turns into a conversation over favorite numbers. Carton learns more about Chris McMonigle and is shocked when Big Mac tells his favorite Yankee of All Time is Wade Boggs! Is that even legal? A caller alerts Craig and C-Mac that while watching them on TV, the description says the co-host is NOT Chris McMonigle!

Jameis Winston has been announced to be part of opening day on Netflix. Carton is not a fan of the idea!

Abdul Carter goes full Kobe Bryant and changes his number after one season That turns into a conversation over favorite numbers.

Carton learns more about Chris McMonigle and is shocked when Big Mac tells his favorite Yankee of All Time is Wade Boggs! Is that even legal?

A caller alerts Craig and C-Mac that while watching them on TV, the description says the co-host is NOT Chris McMonigle!

Things start calm… and then COMPLETELY spiral 😅 Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle break down the latest March Madness scores — including a potential UPSET ALERT — before the show takes a wild turn.

Things got WEIRD fast on the Carton Show, Abdul Carter is changing his number to #3, and Craig Carton thinks it says EVERYTHING about his rookie season. Is this a fresh start… or an admission he flopped?

Is there a secret plot against Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle? The studio turns into a crime scene in this segment of The Carton Show as a caller reveals a shocking error on Verizon Fios and Spectrum: the TV guide still lists Craig’s former partner, David Jacoby, as the co-host!

Things are getting HEATED in the Town Fair Tire Studios! 🎙️ In this wild segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle confront the ultimate disrespect before diving into a high-stakes edition of "Friday Fun Bags."

The gloves are off! In this high-octane segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle dive deep into the NBA hierarchy and the New York Knicks' destiny.

Is Jason Giambi the answer for the Jets and the Yankees? A legendary "scam" caller returns to WFAN to pitch the most chaotic roster move in New York sports history!

This segment goes completely OFF THE RAILS Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to one of the most AGGRESSIVE emails you’ll ever hear… sent by their own producer

Is NOTHING sacred anymore?! On this wild segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go head-to-head over one shocking decision: Netflix putting Jameis Winston on the Opening Day broadcast for Yankees vs. Giants. Carton calls it a DISRESPECTFUL gimmick ruining one of baseball’s most sacred traditions… while Big Mac says: RELAX, it’s supposed to be FUN!

Craig opens up by giving predictions on the NCAA tournament. Plus, we dive into the nine hot dogs nine beers in nine innings promotion. NFL flag football draws less interest than baseball spring training games. People need to stop complaining about the New York Yankees spending money. C-Mac has a bone to pick with the Boston Red Sox after Gerrit Cole's return to the mound begins with a bunt. This sets off the callers! During the handing out of the silver medals during the WBC, we noticed a random person handing them out to team USA. After some digging, we've found out who it is and how important of a role he has.

Craig opens up by giving predictions on the NCAA tournament. Plus, we dive into the nine hot dogs nine beers in nine innings promotion.

C-Mac has a bone to pick with the Boston Red Sox after Gerrit Cole's return to the mound begins with a bunt. This sets off the callers!

During the handing out of the silver medals during the WBC, we noticed a random person handing them out to team USA. After some digging, we've found out who it is and how important of a role he has.

The rivalry never sleeps! In this segment of The Carton Show, Chris McMonigle (C-Mac) and Craig Carton dive deep into the "mind games" being played between the New York Yankees and the Boston Red Sox. C-Mac explains why a simple spring training bunt against a returning Gerrit Cole was actually a calculated message from Alex Cora.

March Madness is officially HERE, and the upsets are already shaking the foundations of every bracket except for Pete’s? Craig and C-Mac break down High Point’s massive upset over Wisconsin and the hilarious "Lazy River" recruiting tactic that might be the secret to their success.

Chris McMonigle and Craig Carton go wild talking March Madness bracket chaos, insane odds in the quintillions, and the first-ever AI “digital twin” of WNBA star Kelsey Plum that fans can actually call! Plus, they dive into outrageous historical rumors about Abraham Lincoln and wild Roman orgy stories.

The tournament is heating up, but the drama in the Bronx is boiling over! Craig Carton and Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle break down the massive upsets on the court before diving into a heated debate over the New York Yankees. Is Aaron Boone making a massive mistake with the rotation?

Chris McMonigle and Craig Carton dive into the wild “9-9-9 Challenge” at the ballpark, tiny hot dogs, mini beers, and insane drinking stories from college days! From Rizzuto’s legendary radio calls to the infamous Century Club, these guys share the craziest ballpark eating and drinking challenges you’ve never heard of. Who could really handle all that in nine innings? Tune in for laughs, disbelief, and epic nostalgia!

This segment goes OFF the rails fast , Craig Carton has ZERO interest in Team USA flag football and absolutely lets it fly when the topic even gets mentioned. Tune in for another jam packed segment of the Carton Show

An emotional announcement turns into a heated debate as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to longtime Mets voice Howie Rose calling it a career after this season.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle kick off the show in absolute chaos as Carton declares it “Father’s Day”… in March?! That quickly spirals into a hilarious debate about tournament time, office bracket warriors, and why nobody cares about your picks.

The WFAN team breaks down Team USA's 3-2 loss to Venezuela in the WBC Final, highlighting the offensive struggles of Aaron Judge. The hosts debate whether the loss falls on manager Mark DeRosa's shoulders or if it’s another sign of Judge’s inability to perform in clutch postseason moments.

From 'Baseball Isn't Boring' (subscribe here): Bradfo catches up with Mets Pitcher Nolan McLean after the WBC to quickly reflect on his WBC experience, what he learned, and what he'll take with him moving forward To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

The strays fly from the open of the show as Aaron Judge is public enemy number one. Does Judge deserve the criticism? Team USA won the WBC in 2017, yet no one remembers because no one cared. All of a sudden, Aaron Judge fails and USA loses and everyone is up in arms. It doesn't make any sense! Bryce Harper was pumped after tying the game up in the 8th inning of the WBC Finals. Was Aaron Judge trying to tell Harper to chill? Chris Christie calls in to Craig and Big Mac to console the latter after a rough day on air. The Yankee shill has done a great job of defending Aaron Judges honor. Plus, the wheel has been taken out and Craig gives it a spin or two!

The strays fly from the open of the show as Aaron Judge is public enemy number one. Does Judge deserve the criticism?

Team USA won the WBC in 2017, yet no one remembers because no one cared. All of a sudden, Aaron Judge fails and USA loses and everyone is up in arms. It doesn't make any sense!

Bryce Harper was pumped after tying the game up in the 8th inning of the WBC Finals. Was Aaron Judge trying to tell Harper to chill?

Chris Christie calls in to Craig and Big Mac to console the latter after a rough day on air. The Yankee shill has done a great job of defending Aaron Judges honor. Plus, the wheel has been taken out and Craig gives it a spin or two!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive deep into the most overrated moment in Knicks history! Was Willis Reed’s iconic Game 7 entrance really that important, or did Clyde Frazier steal the show with one of the greatest performances ever? Plus, reactions to WNBA news and a surprise update from Punch the Monkey! Knicks fans, get ready for hot takes you won’t forget.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the fiery debate over whether the World Baseball Classic can rival the World Series! Did Derek Jeter really take a shot at Aaron Judge, or is it all about the atmosphere? Plus, Yankee fans get relief as Austin Wells dominates the WBC and earns All-Tournament catcher honors. Who are the real winners of the WBC? Find out now!

On today’s Carton Show with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle, Big Mac defends Aaron Judge after a tough WBC night, gets a surprise call from former New Jersey Governor Chris Christie, and then Gallo & Hoff face Big Mac in another edition of "Spin That Wheel"

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down everything from Aaron Judge’s “choke” moment to the untold truths about The Beatles’ breakup — plus the wild history behind the Masters Champions Dinner! Did Bryce Harper and Judge really clash on the field? Who pays for the legendary Masters dinner? And which shocking Beatles facts will blow your mind? Tune in for laughs, sports debates, and iconic rock history on The Carton Show!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the wildest examples of pro athletes completely out of touch with reality! Max Crosby complains about flying first class instead of private, while Rory McIlroy orders a ridiculously bougie Masters dinner featuring Le Bernardin tuna carpaccio, elk sliders, Wagyu filet, and $1,000 bottles of wine! Who’s really lost touch with the common man? Plus, talk about Aaron Judge, international baseball, and some hot takes on food, travel, and sports culture.

Things got PERSONAL fast on WFAN as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go head-to-head over one simple question…

The New York Yankees narrative just won’t die… and after last night, it’s LOUDER than ever. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down Team USA’s brutal loss in the World Baseball Classic and why all eyes are back on Aaron Judge.

The fallout from Team USA’s loss in the World Baseball Classic is getting HEATED… and now New York Mets fans are piling on?!

Will the WBC be a major part of Aaron Judges career or is this a blip on the radar? In a world where college athletes get paid a ton of money, Aden Holloway gets arrested for having over 2 pounds of weed on him. When you call in the one rule is, you best be listening. Anthony found out the hard way! Lil Wayne joins Craig and Big Mac to talk sports and his show coming to Jones Beach in September!

For Aaron Judge, he hopes that's not the case! Will the WBC be a major part of Aaron Judges career or is this a blip on the radar?

In a world where college athletes get paid a ton of money, Aden Holloway gets arrested for having over 2 pounds of weed on him.

When you call in the one rule is, you best be listening. Anthony found out the hard way!