The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go OFF on Francisco Lindor after a brutal mental mistake early in the game that had everyone asking: how do you not know how many outs there are?!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open the show with a fiery takedown of Francisco Lindor after a shocking mental lapse in the first inning against the Cardinals.

Carton is furious that the basketball hall of fame elected a bunch of compilers this year. Plus, Giancarlo sits and Yankee fans won't have access to tampons in the mens room. It's the baseball term that most people know when we come to the third game of a split series, the rubber Match. But where does it come from?

Carton is furious that the basketball hall of fame elected a bunch of compilers this year. Plus, Giancarlo sits and Yankee fans won't have access to tampons in the mens room.

It's the baseball term that most people know when we come to the third game of a split series, the rubber Match. But where does it come from?

The New York Yankees are just FIVE games into the season… and fans are already calling for trades?! Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle react to some early overreactions, including takes on Jasson Domínguez, the rotation, and whether the Yankees should make moves this early.

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle dive into one of the wildest off-field stories of the season, an update on the tampon controversy at New York Yankees games ahead of Opening Day at Yankee Stadium. What’s actually happening and what changed? Plus, the guys keep the debate rolling on the controversial Basketball Hall of Fame class, including opinions on Doc Rivers and Amar'e Stoudemire.

The New York Yankees are off to a scorching start in 2026 and their pitching staff might already be the BEST in baseball. Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle break down the Yankees' early dominance, including a stellar outing from Max Fried and surprising contributions across the rotation and bullpen.

It may not be accurate, but the message of positivity that Aaron Glenn is sending to his team is the right message. Unfortunately, no one believes that he's on the path to success. That's right, Mark Messier wasn't important at all when it comes down to the New York Rangers winning the Stanley Cup in 1994! Plus, Disney adults are real. Chris McMonigle embarrasses himself on live radio as he loses a game "Do you know you know more sports than a 7 year old". Also, Tiger Woods is caught with pills, but the media doesn't care about that, how's his golf game? Jerry Recco makes a surprise phone call to the Carton Show after we discovered some scungilli at the office. Plus, for the first time in the history of WFAN the ladies take over the airwaves!

It may not be accurate, but the message of positivity that Aaron Glenn is sending to his team is the right message. Unfortunately, no one believes that he's on the path to success.

That's right, Mark Messier wasn't important at all when it comes down to the New York Rangers winning the Stanley Cup in 1994! Plus, Disney adults are real.

Chris McMonigle embarrasses himself on live radio as he loses a game "Do you know you know more sports than a 7 year old". Also, Tiger Woods is caught with pills, but the media doesn't care about that, how's his golf game?

Jerry Recco makes a surprise phone call to the Carton Show after we discovered some scungilli at the office. Plus, for the first time in the history of WFAN the ladies take over the airwaves!

Chris McMonigle and Craig Carton break down the Yankees’ first loss of the season—and the fan backlash aimed at Aaron Boone. Was Boone really to blame, or is the Yankees’ offense the real issue after a 2-1 loss?

A historic (and hilarious) moment on The Carton Show! For the first time ever, EVERY caller on the lines is a woman! From passionate Yankees talk to debates about weight loss, Italian food (macaroni vs. pasta!), and even a wild story involving Coca-Cola and Vitaminwater

Things get REAL on the WFAN airwaves as Craig Carton goes to bat for Chris McMonigle after constant shots about his weight and he’s NOT having it.

An all-time moment on The Carton Show!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the New York Yankees tough 2-1 loss and the fan backlash aimed at manager Aaron Boone. Was Boone actually to blame… or are fans ignoring the real issue — the offense?

On this episode of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the real reason the Yankees dropped their first game of the season. From the bullpen decisions to the lack of hitting, they call out the overreactions and defend Boone against the online outrage.

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle bring the laughs in this hilarious segment as they introduce the legendary (and completely made-up?) “Yankee Pledge Day”, where fans must make a 27-second promise to the baseball gods for a World Series title.

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle kick off the show reacting to stunning comments from Jets head coach Aaron Glenn, who doubled down on his belief that Geno Smith can lead the team to the “Promised Land.”

The WFAN team is joined by coaching legend Bobby Hurley Sr. to discuss his son's coaching legacy following a thrilling victory over Duke. Plus, we break down St. John’s tough exit and debate what Rick Pitino could have done differently to change the outcome.

From ‘Go Get ‘Em’ (Subscribe Here): Chris McMonigle reacts to a season-opening sweep of the Giants, including the early optimism for Camilo Doval and the Yankee bullpen, the brilliance of Cam Schlittler and what it means for the big picture, and frustration with sitting Ben Rice against a lefty immediately. Plus, Giancarlo Stanton looks as locked in as he's ever been during his Yankee tenure, the ABS challenge system has been great for the game, and looking ahead to a series in Seattle with some sexy pitching matchups. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Craig opens the show talking about St. Johns loss to Duke and how maybe we've overhyped them a tad bit. Plus, it's been 3 games and Bo Bichette is already getting booed by Mets fans. Legendary Coach Bob Hurley joins Craig and C-Mac to talk about an amazing UCONN win by his son Danny Hurley over Duke to move on to the Final 4. Plus, the chaos continues in Jets land as Aaron Glenn announces he has a starting QB. A lot of complaints over the weekend from Mets fans watching on the SNY App regarding commercials. Especially the only one that seemed to run constantly. Plus, Knicks lost to Thunder again and no one seems to care. You know what that means? Get us to the playoffs already! That's right, one of the best films of Jim Carrey's career is under fire by Craig Carton.

Craig opens the show talking about St. Johns loss to Duke and how maybe we've overhyped them a tad bit. Plus, it's been 3 games and Bo Bichette is already getting booed by Mets fans.

Legendary Coach Bob Hurley joins Craig and C-Mac to talk about an amazing UCONN win by his son Danny Hurley over Duke to move on to the Final 4. Plus, the chaos continues in Jets land as Aaron Glenn announces he has a starting QB.

A lot of complaints over the weekend from Mets fans watching on the SNY App regarding commercials. Especially the only one that seemed to run constantly. Plus, Knicks lost to Thunder again and no one seems to care. You know what that means? Get us to the playoffs already!

That's right, one of the best films of Jim Carrey's career is under fire by Craig Carton.

Things go completely off the rails on the Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle get into a HEATED (and hilarious) debate over classic movies. Is "Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls" actually GOOD?!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the latest New York Jets drama as Aaron Glenn doubles down on Geno Smith being the unquestioned starting QB and fans are NOT happy.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into a wild mix of stories, from Tiger Woods controversy to a bizarre 12-ton chocolate heist and somehow it all turns into a social media firestorm.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to Aaron Glenn officially naming Geno Smith the New York Jets’ starting quarterback and they are NOT buying the hype. Carton goes OFF on Glenn’s comments, questioning why the Jets are ignoring Geno’s recent struggles and handing him the keys with zero competition. Is this confidence or delusion?

Legendary high school basketball coach Bob Hurley Sr. joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on WFAN for an incredible conversation. -Thoughts on Dan Hurley’s coaching dominance and fiery style 🔥 -Inside the Hurley family legacy in basketball -Reaction to Duke’s latest heartbreak and the tournament drama -Coaching philosophy that built one of the greatest high school programs ever -Stories from decades on the sidelines and developing elite talent

Craig and Big Mac talk a big weekend of NY baseball and the Duke debate continues. Is Duke hatred generational or just part of being a fan? And why are Yankees fans so quiet during a perfect start?

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into one of the WILDEST debates yet, are Yankees fans really NOT optimistic?!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to a WILD weekend in sports! Duke blows a 19-point lead to UConn in a shocking collapse, Carton unloads on the Blue Devils and explains why he LOVES seeing Duke lose, Debate over whether UConn deserves the hype or if fans are overreacting, St. John’s expectations vs reality, Mets take the series… but fans are already BOOING?!, Early-season frustrations with Bo Bichette, Juan Soto & the offense

Hear from the best guests of the week on WFAN, including Keith Hernandez, Steve Schirripa (14:54), Ron Darling (47:21), Nick Swisher (1:01:17), and Ian Eagle (1:11:02).

The Mets started off the season with a bang, and our hosts have all the instant reaction to a memorable Opening Day, from Carson Benge's MLB intro to the new-look lineup rallying against Paul Skenes. Plus, Evan's journey to finding his wallet that he lost en route to the game!

The Mets win in the home opener, but during the 1st inning, before Paul Skenes even touched the mound, a man in section 121 suffered a medical emergency. Thankfully for him, there were people around him who jumped into action and helped save his life. Dr. Alyssa, calls in along with Chris, a security guard, and another good Samaritan, Jordan. The man himself, Martin, the person who had the medical emergency checks in with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle to thank everyone involved in saving his life.

The Mets win in the home opener, but during the 1st inning, before Paul Skenes even touched the mound, a man in section 121 suffered a medical emergency. Thankfully for him, there were people around him who jumped into action and helped save his life. Dr. Alyssa, calls in along with Chris, a security guard, and another good Samaritan, Jordan.

The man himself, Martin, the person who had the medical emergency checks in with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle to thank everyone involved in saving his life.

The story comes full circle. After a shocking medical emergency during Mets Opening Day at Citi Field, the fan at the center of it all joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle live on WFAN. Martin shares what he remembers from the moment he collapsed, reveals it was NOT a heart attack, and delivers an emotional thank you to the Good Samaritans, ER doctor, and first responders who rushed to save him. From chaos in the stands to walking out of the hospital the same night — this is an incredible, feel-good New York story you don’t want to miss.

An unbelievable and emotional story out of Opening Day at Citi Field. During the Mets’ home opener, a fan suffered a medical emergency in the stands — but thanks to quick action from a Good Samaritan, an ER doctor, NYPD, and stadium staff, his life was saved. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the incredible chain of events, including firsthand accounts from the doctor and the fan who performed CPR. From chaos to celebration, this is one of the most powerful sports stories you’ll hear all year. Plus, reactions to the Mets’ win, the Yankees staying undefeated, and more from a packed Friday show.

The Yankees rolled to victory in their season opener, and our hosts have all the instant reactions, ranging from the game itself to the broadcast on Netflix and what to make of Aaron Judge's rough night.

Baseballs opening day was great for Yankee fans, but bad for baseball? Barry Bonds told a story during the Yankees game that George Steinbrenner gave him an offer to be the highest paid baseball player, but it had a deadline on. Gelly Rello poked holes in the story. After knocking out Paul Skenes in the first inning, the Mets went on to beat the Pirates 11-7 for another opening day win. Mets fans should walk away Thursday with a smile on their faces after an 11-7 victory over Paul Skenes and the Pirates. Unfortunately, most people who drove left frustrated due to parking.

Baseballs opening day was great for Yankee fans, but bad for baseball?

Barry Bonds told a story during the Yankees game that George Steinbrenner gave him an offer to be the highest paid baseball player, but it had a deadline on. Gelly Rello poked holes in the story.

From ‘Go Get ‘Em’ (Subscribe Here): C-Mac gives his takeaways from a dominant Yankee win to begin the season! From the encouraging production by the bottom of the order to Max Fried's dominance, there was little to complain about in the 7-0 rout. Chris called out fans who were getting on Aaron Judge for his rough night (18:00), ripped the quality of the Netflix broadcast (24:00), and reacted to Barry Bonds' shocking story that George Steinbrenner nearly made him a Yankee (41:00). To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

After knocking out Paul Skenes in the first inning, the Mets went on to beat the Pirates 11-7 for another opening day win.

Mets fans should walk away Thursday with a smile on their faces after an 11-7 victory over Paul Skenes and the Pirates. Unfortunately, most people who drove left frustrated due to parking.