The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dive into the impact Dexter Lawrence’s trade request could have on the Giants’ draft plans. Plus, Pat Leonard joins The Carton Show to detail more behind the drama between the Giants and Dex (20:07); Evan & Tiki debate Sonny Styles vs. Jeremiyah Love with the No. 5 pick (39:33); Boomer & Gio on why the Giants have the best head coach/QB combo in the NFL (56:37).

Boomer & Gio on the Knicks’ win over the Celtics and if there’s anything to take away from it heading into the postseason. Plus, Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash discuss expectations from Knicks fans this postseason (14:16), and whether or not the Knicks face an NBA Finals or bust kind of pressure (28:35); Craig Carton looks ahead to the likely Knicks playoff seeding and schedule (41:03).

The Yankee offense has looked lifeless for much of the season, and Craig Carton sounded off on how "unwatchable" the lineup has been. The Evan and Tiki crew debate what the team should do about Ryan McMahon, and Shaun Morash has a hysterical story about meeting David Wells at a bar. Mike Vaccaro of the New York Post joins the midday show to discuss his new book on the Steinbrenner family.

The Mets moved up two of their start times, and Steve Cohen made it known via social media that he was not happy with the attendance. Craig Carton says the Mets owner is losing a fanbase that he seems to "hate," while Evan Roberts sounded off on the fans that accepted free tickets and didn't show up. Plus, will Juan Soto's calf injury carry lingering concerns related to a potential future Achilles injury?

From ‘Go Get ‘Em’ (Subscribe Here): Chris McMonigle reacts to the Yankees' first series loss of the season, and sounds off on how putrid the lineup has looked for most of the season, including the middle of the order suddenly slipping into a funk. Ryan Weathers turned in a great start in Thursday's series finale, but the bats could not produce a single run. Plus, C-Mac is convinced Anthony Volpe has already won back the starting shortstop job given how poorly Jose Caballero has played. Chris has a major issue with Aaron Judge not being more aggressive using ABS challenges, and wraps the show up by recapping the A's series and reacting to the news of Cade Winquest being DFA'd. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze the New York Mets' defensive struggles and the offensive slumps plaguing New York baseball. They celebrate the Knicks' victory over the Celtics and discuss the suspension of Dianna Russini following investigations into her relationship with Mike Vrabel. Guest Nikki Gist provides a unique perspective on the New York Giants and the challenges facing female insiders in the sports media landscape.

Craig and Big Mac analyze the Mets' defensive strategy following a frustrating loss and the lack of offensive production from both New York baseball teams. They dive into a wild conspiracy theory regarding Bill Belichick’s potential involvement in the Mike Vrabel and Dianna Russini scandal. Additionally, they discuss the Knicks' victory over the Celtics and debate the proper terminology for RBIs. 01:20 - Mets Defensive Strategy Farce 06:45 - New York Baseball Power Outage 12:10 - The Great Analytics Debate 16:04 - Knicks Lock Up Three Seed 23:20 - Mark Jones Leaves ESPN 26:50 - Belichick and the Vrabel Scandal 37:03 - Miguel Rojas and Playoff Expectations 47:30 - The RBIs vs RBI Argument

Nikki Gist joins the show to discuss the controversial rumors surrounding Mike Vrabel and Diana Russini, emphasizing the negative impact these allegations have on women in sports media. They also explore the usage of baseball acronyms with feedback from Michael Kay and react to the awkward unveiling of a broken Ichiro Suzuki statue. 01:50 - Grammatical Pet Peeves 05:20 - Michael Kay Text Exchange 11:30 - Baseball Analytics Debate 17:10 - Metric System Struggle 27:10 - Teacher Appreciation Discussion 33:05 - Ichiro Statue & Statues 47:15 - Nikki Gist Interview 01:10:30 - Media Ethics Discussion

Craig and Big Mac dive into the polarizing topic of video tributes for returning players like Jeff McNeil and Pete Alonso. They also explore the strange statistics of the Yankees' early-season success despite a struggling lineup and offer advice to a caller on which jersey to buy. The conversation shifts from sports to local culture, featuring a debate over Italian cheeses and the impact of social media influencers on New York City's bagel shops. 01:20 - Absent NFL Players 02:52 - Media Double Standards 10:02 - Yankees Batting Averages 19:05 - Jersey Purchase Advice 24:22 - McNeil Video Debate 34:45 - Cheese Consistency Debate 38:09 - NYC Bagel Influencers

They analyze reports that The Athletic suspended Dianna Russini while investigating her relationship with Mike Vrabel and its impact on her NFL reporting. Between segments, a trivia game tests their knowledge of sports history and pop culture connections. 01:15 - Russini Suspension Update 04:55 - Carton Show Connection 08:05 - Gallo Joins Game 14:28 - Connections Round Two 18:20 - Big Mac Competes 23:15 - Dice Clay Impressions 26:30 - Russini Tampering Debate

Big Mac, Hoff, and Gallo compete in the Carton Show Connection trivia challenge, testing their knowledge on the New York Mets and classic sitcoms. The competition transitions into a debate over Bill Cosby impressions and a retelling of a legendary interview with comedian Andrew Dice Clay. 01:00 - The Carton Show Connection Trivia 10:14 - Second Round Trivia Challenge 16:03 - Celebrity Impression Debates 19:10 - Andrew Dice Clay Story

Big Mac and Craig debate whether former Mets star Jeff McNeil deserves a tribute video upon his return to Citi Field. They also break down the difference between burrata and stracciatella cheese before exploring the impact of social media influencers on iconic New York City bagel shops. 01:01 - Intro And Pitcher Confusion 02:46 - McNeil Tribute Video Debate 10:33 - Soft Tribute Video Culture 12:11 - Burrata Cheese Consistency Debate 15:45 - NYC Influencer Bagel Lines

The guys dive into how something like that even happens, how much these statues really cost, and whether it can even be fixed. Plus, Carton shares an unbelievable story about commissioning a five-figure Tom Seaver statue as a gift, while the conversation hilariously shifts to The Beatles memorabilia, fake vs real autographs, and awkward gift-giving moments.

Things got REAL on The Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle bring on rising NFL insider Nikki to break down the controversial Mike Vrabel–Dianna Russini situation and she does NOT hold back. Nikki sounds off on the impact this scandal could have on women in sports media, the double standards in the industry, and the challenges of being taken seriously as an insider. Plus, she pushes back on Russini’s reporting and shares her own experience navigating the business.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle mock producer Pete Hoffman for his inability to understand basic measurement conversions. They later discuss the merits of the teaching profession and share stories from their elementary school days. 01:00 - Metric System Debate 03:48 - Meters Versus Yards Confusion 07:41 - Yankees And Mets Talk 14:15 - Teacher Appreciation Debate

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into one of the most ridiculous (and hilarious) debates in sports: is it RBI or RBIs? It starts with a simple text to Aaron Boone and quickly spirals into a full-blown argument involving grammar, baseball tradition, and even “woke” terminology. Then things escalate when Carton texts Michael Kay LIVE on air and confirms what Yankees fans will love.

On WFAN’s Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive back into the Mike Vrabel–Dianna Russini controversy but Craig introduces a completely wild new theory involving Bill Belichick that has everyone cracking up.

Craig Carton and Big Mac critique the defensive struggles and offensive drought plaguing both the Mets and the Yankees. They celebrate the New York Knicks' victory over the Celtics and discuss the team's playoff positioning before introducing a new game called Carton Show Connections. 01:00 - Mets Defensive Woes 07:19 - Baseball Power Outage 11:40 - Analytics Statistics Debate 15:33 - Knicks Playoff Seeding 21:00 - Connections Game Preview

From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): Strawweight Tatiana Suarez joins Hoff to discuss her upcoming fight with Loopy Godinez at UFC 327. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze the New York Yankees' recent scoring drought following a frustrating series against the Oakland Athletics. They critique Aaron Judge’s passive approach to the challenge system and discuss the defensive-heavy decisions being made by the front office. On The Carton Show, they also examine Knicks playoff scenarios and vent about the stadium experience at Yankee Stadium. 01:55 - Yankees' Scoreless Inning Streak 06:40 - Roster Decisions And Struggles 12:50 - Boone's Strategy Critiqued 17:15 - Aaron Judge's Passive Approach 21:35 - Media Protection Of Russini 26:40 - Fans Venting On Lineup 33:15 - George Lombard Jr. Hype 37:45 - Stadium Music Volume Issues 42:40 - Minor League Baseball Promotions 47:20 - Yankees' Lack Of Edge 51:45 - Knicks' Ideal Playoff Seeding 56:20 - Yankee Stadium Food Shortages 01:00:55 - Managing Bench Depth Concerns 01:05:50 - NFL Draft YouTube Special 01:10:25 - Classic Movie Title Parodies 01:17:15 - Consistency In Media Reporting

Carton and Big Mac tear into the New York Yankees after the offense went 17 consecutive innings without a run or significant hits. They debate Aaron Judge's lack of aggression with the automated strike challenge system and question Randal Grichuk's future roster spot. The conversation on the Carton Show also covers the loud music at Yankee Stadium and a heated caller's rant about the team's postseason prospects. 01:50 - Yankees Scoreless Inning Streak 06:41 - Randal Grichuk Roster Decisions 13:02 - Pinch Running Strategy Debate 18:01 - Aaron Judge ABS Challenges 22:25 - Big Mac Stadium Experience 29:37 - Caller Rants Yankee Trash 37:01 - Yankee Stadium Music Volume 45:41 - Yankee Leadership And Edge

Craig and Big Mac debate the strategic advantages of the Knicks securing a fourth seed versus a third seed in the upcoming playoffs. They express frustration over the Yankees' scoring drought and the lack of popular food items at the stadium. Conversations also cover media ethics in sports reporting and heartfelt calls from listeners praising the duo's on-air chemistry. 01:20 - Knicks Seeding Debate 04:45 - Stadium Food Woes 10:04 - Yankees Scoreless Streak 16:25 - NFL Draft Special 21:05 - Jokes And Pop Culture 25:50 - Media Reporting Ethics 33:45 - Sentimental Listener Calls 38:25 - Show Wrap Up

Chris McMonigle examines the Yankees' offensive slump and the specific struggles of Ryan McMahon and the bottom of the order on The Carton Show. He questions Aaron Boone's decision to keep Paul Goldschmidt on the bench during a shutout loss and looks at the impact of the high strikeout rate. They also pivot to a lighthearted debate over the musical catalogs of R.E.M. and The B-52's. 01:20 - Yankee Postseason Expectations 05:50 - Ryan McMahon Concerns 11:28 - Ryan Weathers Dominance 15:20 - Yankee Bench Depth 18:22 - Music Catalog Debates 25:36 - Offensive Strikeout Issues 31:45 - Potential Trade Targets 36:25 - Postseason Roster Strategy

The guys also dive back into Yankees concerns, including questions about the infield, lineup construction, and whether it’s too early to panic just 12 games into the season. Plus, a continuation of the media debate surrounding recent reporting controversies and consistency in coverage.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down a fascinating debate: is the 4-seed actually better than the 3-seed for the Knicks heading into the playoffs? With potential matchups against Philly, Atlanta, and Detroit, the path to the Eastern Conference Finals might not be so straightforward. PLUS, things take a turn at Yankee Stadium

In this fiery segment from WFAN’s Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to a brutal stretch of Yankees offense, including a passionate caller ripping the lineup apart and calling out the team’s lack of “edge.”

The Yankees may be 8-4, but don’t let the record fool you, something is OFF. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down a frustrating series loss to the A’s where the Yankees’ offense completely disappeared, 17 scoreless innings, no clutch hitting, and major concerns in the lineup.

The discussion covers the viral scandal involving NFL insider Dianna Russini and coach Mike Vrabel, debating the implications of their alleged rendezvous in Arizona. The conversation shifts to Mets owner Steve Cohen’s public frustration with fans over unused free tickets and the contrasting attendance at Yankee Stadium. They also touch on the Yankees' recent performance, a controversial MSG fan figure, and the Wednesday Wheel of Fun trivia segment. 01:50 - Intro and Yankees Win 06:26 - Dianna Russini Scandal Analysis 11:42 - Patriots Culture and Belichick 16:48 - Steve Cohen’s Twitter War 23:41 - Yankees Lineup and Rosario 29:30 - Podcast Success and Media 34:40 - Artisanal Bread and Culture 39:56 - Mike Vrabel’s Viral Quote 45:47 - Big Mac Health Update 53:51 - Dancing Larry Harassment Story 59:20 - Courtside vs Press Credentials 01:05:07 - Social Etiquette and Wings 01:10:13 - Syracuse vs St. Johns 15:10 - Wheel of Fun: Jets 20:44 - Wheel of Fun: Nicknames 27:32 - Mark Leiter Jr. Role 32:00 - Dianna Russini Marital History

Carton and Big Mac dive into the scandalous allegations involving NFL insider Dianna Russini and Mike Vrabel, debating how a private hotel encounter affects professional credibility. They also examine Steve Cohen's social media frustrations with Mets fans after a poor turnout for a rescheduled game. The conversation concludes with an analysis of New York baseball results and the unique culture of the New England Patriots. 01:42 - Russini-Vrabel Scandal 11:53 - Patriots Organizational Culture 15:20 - Steve Cohen Ticket Dispute 20:58 - Scandal Photo Analysis 27:57 - Listener Call-In 38:25 - Russini Professional History 49:38 - Yankees Lineup Management

Craig Carton and Big Mac dissect Steve Cohen's social media post criticizing fans who didn't attend a free ticket game. They look into the lack of coverage on the Mike Vrabel and Dianna Russini rumors and weigh in on the Yankees' latest roster moves. 01:41 - Media Silence on Mike Vrabel 06:14 - Steve Cohen's Ticket Controversy 13:05 - Analyzing the Mets' Empty Stadium 18:08 - Proposing a Fan Promotion Ban 23:11 - Yankees Lineup and Injury Updates 28:45 - Mets Fans Defend Start Times 36:17 - Prepping for the Wheel of Fun 41:00 - Discussion on Comp Ticket Resale 45:42 - Kat in Brooklyn Talks Music 50:57 - Fans Sabotaging Mets Promotions

Craig and Big Mac analyze the rumors surrounding Mike Vrabel and Dianna Russini following reports of them attending a concert together. They also discuss a recent on-field brawl between the Angels and Braves, look into the legal issues facing Dancing Larry at Madison Square Garden, and reflect on their respective career paths in broadcasting. 01:20 - Mike Vrabel Rumors 04:10 - Baseball Fight Suspensions 10:10 - NFL Insider Speculation 13:20 - National Media Access 17:30 - Responding To Scandals 23:55 - Dancing Larry Lawsuit 28:40 - MSG Press Credentials 32:45 - Social Etiquette Debate 37:30 - Big Mac Career History

Craig Carton breaks down the scandalous rumors involving Dianna Russini and Mike Vrabel at an Arizona resort while critiquing the media's double standards. They also discuss a bizarre chess cheating scandal, the difficulty of separating art from the artist, and the current state of the Yankees and Mets. 01:21 - Dianna Russini Scandal 05:42 - Stadium Traditions Debate 10:14 - Syracuse Media Legacy 14:55 - Wednesday Wheel Fun 16:32 - Chess Cheating Scandal 19:46 - Pedro Martinez Critiques 23:30 - Yankees And Mets Updates 28:10 - Media Double Standards

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the bizarre controversy surrounding “Dancing Larry” at Madison Square Garden, including shocking allegations, legal trouble, and whether MSG should be held responsible. The conversation quickly turns into a lively debate about fan behavior, public perception, and how far is too far for in-arena personalities. Plus, the guys mix in their signature humor and banter as callers weigh in on the situation and other random topics. Another classic WFAN moment full of takes, laughs, and unexpected turns.

The WFAN crew brings the chaos in this hilarious “Wheel of Fun” segment on The Carton Show! Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle put the pressure on as Anthony Gallo goes on a HEATER, naming 12 New York Jets first-round picks to steal the crown! But the real moment? An ALL-TIME collapse in the sports nickname round 🤯

On this segment of WFAN’s Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down a chaotic MLB brawl between the Angels and Braves, including a shocking moment where a pitcher nearly threw punches while holding a baseball.

This Carton Show segment has EVERYTHING, hilarious listener interactions to more fallout from the Mets ticket controversy. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle take a call from “Kat in Brooklyn,” leading to a funny (and slightly outrageous) back-and-forth about singing, “artisanal” bread, and even a wild invite to the studio.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to unexpected breaking news during the show — the Yankees shake up their lineup in a BIG way. Ryan McMahon is back but not where you’d expect, as he slots in at SHORTSTOP while Rosario stays hot at third base.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to Steve Cohen’s controversial tweet about Mets fans not showing up, even after free tickets! Was it fair criticism or a massive PR mistake? The guys break down why the tweet may have backfired and what it really says about the Mets’ relationship with their fanbase.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle continue to unload on Mets owner Steve Cohen as the fan backlash grows following his free ticket comments and social media antics. With the Mets winning games but Citi Field still empty, the guys question Cohen’s decisions and whether he’s creating a full-blown war with the fanbase.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle kick off the show with a MASSIVE day in sports, from a wild Yankees comeback win to the Mets staying hot without Juan Soto. But the real fireworks come off the field.

The WFAN team breaks down Dexter Lawrence’s trade request and the brewing tension with new head coach Jim Harbaugh. Is the Giants' defensive anchor transforming into New York’s next big villain?

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle criticize the New York Mets for rescheduling games due to mild cold, contrasting them with the tougher New York Yankees. They also analyze John Harbaugh's comments on Dexter Lawrence's trade request and discuss Fernando Mendoza skipping the NFL Draft.