The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Things get heated on The Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate the New York Giants shocking move to bring back Evan Neal.

The debate keeps getting hotter on The Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle continue arguing about the New York Giants bringing back Evan Neal. Carton says the move is embarrassing for Big Blue and can’t believe Giants fans are defending it after Neal’s disastrous play and his infamous “lion doesn’t concern himself with sheep” comment about the fanbase. Meanwhile, Big Mac tries to calm things down, arguing it’s just a veteran minimum flyer that doesn’t really matter.

The New York Giants are bringing back Evan Neal and Craig Carton cannot believe it. On The Carton Show, Craig and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle react to the shocking decision to re-sign the former 7th overall pick to a one-year veteran minimum deal. Carton rips the move, calling Neal one of the biggest draft busts in franchise history and questioning why a new regime would keep a player who represents years of failure for Big Blue.

Who's to blame for a team USA being on the brink of elimination? Nolan McLean who pitched like crap? Aaron Judge who struck out to end the game as the tying run? Or Mark DeRosa who forgot the rules of the WBC? Daniel Jones gets paid again! But How? The often injured, never won anything, former Giants QB strikes another deal for $88Mil! Plus, does anyone know the rules on how USA can advance to the next round of the WBC? Two former NBA players, Tim Hardaway Sr. and Metta World Peace, call in to speak with Craig & Big Mac. Both are old school hard nose players, which is why what they say may surprise you about Bam's 83 point game. In the latest version of "Spin That Wheel", C-Mac goes head to head with Gallo in who can name the most former Duke basketball players who also played in the NBA. Plus, Jack Black's mom is a hero!

Who's to blame for a team USA being on the brink of elimination? Nolan McLean who pitched like crap? Aaron Judge who struck out to end the game as the tying run? Or Mark DeRosa who forgot the rules of the WBC?

Daniel Jones gets paid again! But How? The often injured, never won anything, former Giants QB strikes another deal for $88Mil! Plus, does anyone know the rules on how USA can advance to the next round of the WBC?

Two former NBA players, Tim Hardaway Sr. and Metta World Peace, call in to speak with Craig & Big Mac. Both are old school hard nose players, which is why what they say may surprise you about Bam's 83 point game.

In the latest version of "Spin That Wheel", C-Mac goes head to head with Gallo in who can name the most former Duke basketball players who also played in the NBA. Plus, Jack Black's mom is a hero!

Craig Carton and Big Mac are back with the most chaotic WFAN segment yet! Big Mac dominates the “Spin That Wheel” game, naming NBA stars from Duke while hilarity ensues. Plus, a jaw-dropping story about Jack Black’s mom allegedly saving Apollo 13 while giving birth! Sports, trivia, and unbelievable stories collide in this wild hour you can’t miss.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle sit down with Metta World Peace on WFAN’s Carton Show! From coaching a Division II women’s team to breaking down Bam Adebayo’s insane 83-point game, Metta shares his unfiltered thoughts on NBA legends, Kobe Bryant comparisons, LeBron James, Pat Riley’s culture, and why he’s ready to be a head coach in the league. You won’t believe his takes on free throw strategies, scoring records, and one-on-one matchups with the greats!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the wildest story you'll hear all week: a Florida man claims he was kidnapped by a pod of dolphins and forced to build an underwater city with a dolphin named Gerald! How could this be real? Plus, they dive into last night’s NBA chaos as Bam Adebayo sets records in a controversial game that some are calling a total disgrace to basketball. From Atlantis-style dolphin engineering to NBA madness, this segment has it all!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the NBA’s most controversial performance yet, Bam Adebayo scoring 83 points! But was it truly impressive, or a total farce? From 43 free throws to “fake” fouls and Heat culture chaos, they debate whether this record belongs in NBA history. Tim Hardaway Sr. even weighs in LIVE, and the hosts don’t hold back. Find out why this night has NBA fans divided!

On The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to a surprising idea from the National Football League: a Wednesday night game on Thanksgiving Eve. With games already on Thanksgiving, Black Friday, and Christmas, is the NFL officially taking over every holiday? The guys debate whether fans would actually watch or if the biggest party night of the year would kill ratings.

On the The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the shocking news that Daniel Jones signed a massive deal with the Indianapolis Colts worth up to $100 million.

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle break down a wild day in sports on The Carton Show on WFAN. Did the Baltimore Ravens just outplay Tom Brady and the Raiders in the Trey Hendrickson / Maxx Crosby drama? Carton thinks Brady got completely pantsed by Baltimore’s front office.

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle break down the CHAOS after Team USA’s shocking loss in the World Baseball Classic. Aaron Judge had the tying run at the plate and struck out. Now fans are asking the brutal question: can you trust Judge in the clutch?

After discussing the Giants potential heading into the 2026 season, breaking news hits. Geno Smith has been traded to the New York Jets! Is Tom Brady the culprit? Is he the reason why the Jets are stuck with Geno Smith? Darren Lee supposedly used Chat GPT to find out how to cover up a murder after allegedly killing his girlfriend. Some things should not be searched up online. Cal Raleigh has no time for small talk with his Seattle Mariners teammate.

NFL flag football draws less interest than baseball spring training games. People need to stop complaining about the New York Yankees spending money.

After discussing the Giants potential heading into the 2026 season, breaking news hits. Geno Smith has been traded to the New York Jets!

Is Tom Brady the culprit? Is he the reason why the Jets are stuck with Geno Smith?

Darren Lee supposedly used Chat GPT to find out how to cover up a murder after allegedly killing his girlfriend. Some things should not be searched up online.

Cal Raleigh has no time for small talk with his Seattle Mariners teammate.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the wildest sports and pop culture stories of the day! From Tom Brady mistakenly paying tribute to a legend who’s been gone for three years, to Bigfoot sightings in Ohio, and even rare Belgian beer secrets you’ve never heard. Plus, hilarious takes on lunar missions, happy fans, and jaw-dropping anecdotes from listeners.

The Carton Show goes OFF! Geno Smith opens up about his “full circle” moment, Aaron Glenn’s secret plan, and the drama with Frank Reich.

Absolute chaos on WFAN as Craig Carton goes on an all-time rant about the New York Jets bringing back Geno Smith. Carton says the move gives Jets fans PTSD, listing every quarterback who’s started for the team since Geno was drafted, from Ryan Fitzpatrick to Aaron Rodgers, Zach Wilson, and even Mike White. His conclusion? Somehow the Jets are going right back to the beginning.

Things get heated on WFAN as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate the shocking return of Geno Smith to the New York Jets.

Craig Carton and Big Mac break down the New York Jets’ latest quarterback drama! Geno Smith is back but is he the answer or just another LOL Jets moment? Plus, the wild internet rumor offering FIVE first-round picks, Garrett Wilson, and Breece Hall for Patrick Mahomes blew up with MILLIONS of views! We unpack what’s real, what’s fake, and what this means for the Jets’ future.

Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle go OFF on WFAN! From terrifying flying lawnmowers at Shea Stadium to Bigfoot sightings in Ohio, plus the shocking return of Geno Smith to the Jets. Big Mac spills on Yankees, voodoo dolls, crazy sports curses, and even his favorite beach collabs with Jalen Brunson. You won't believe what really happened behind the scenes!

Chaos breaks out on WFAN as Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle react to shocking news: the New York Jets are bringing back Geno Smith. And Carton absolutely loses it. Carton can’t believe the Jets would turn back to a quarterback who struggled during his first run with the team. Even if the deal is cheap, he calls it a “body blow” for Jets fans and rips the franchise for selling this as their best option.

The Carton Show kicks off with chaos! Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle debate whether the New York Giants actually closed the gap with the Philadelphia Eagles after the first wave of NFL free agency. Are Giants fans getting ahead of themselves… or is the NFC East suddenly wide open?

The Jets make a splash as the NFL’s free agent tampering period began on Monday. Boomer Esiason and Greg Giannoti react live to the breaking news that the Jets acquired Minkah Fitzpatrick in a trade with the Dolphins. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber give their take on what this means for the Jets while Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle with their thoughts on the Jets’ busy day.

Giants bring in Isaiah Likely and the Jets build their defense as chaos ensues the opening hours of NFL legal tampering. SNY's Connor Hughes joins Craig and Big Mac to discuss day one of NFL's legal tampering and how Cor'Dale Flott ended up changing his mind last minute! Pat Monahan talks about his new album, new tour, playing golf with Craig and a whole lot more. Plus, the boys rank the signings from the first few hours of legal tampering. New York Giants bring back Jermaine Eluemunor. NBA is ANTI-Wings as they put an end to the Magic City promotion in Atlanta. Plus, what is easier to make, PB&J or Grilled Cheese?

Giants bring in Isaiah Likely and the Jets build their defense as chaos ensues the opening hours of NFL legal tampering.

SNY's Connor Hughes joins Craig and Big Mac to discuss day one of NFL's legal tampering and how Cor'Dale Flott ended up changing his mind last minute!

Pat Monahan talks about his new album, new tour, playing golf with Craig and a whole lot more. Plus, the boys rank the signings from the first few hours of legal tampering.

New York Giants bring back Jermaine Eluemunor. NBA is ANTI-Wings as they put an end to the Magic City promotion in Atlanta. Plus, what is easier to make, PB&J or Grilled Cheese?

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the shocking NBA decision to CANCEL the legendary Magic City promotion at the Atlanta Hawks game, all over one player's complaint! Fans are furious, and Carton doesn’t hold back on Luke Kornet or even Adam Silver. Plus, chaos ensues as the hosts debate PB&J vs. grilled cheese, reveal diner secrets, and throw in pop culture trivia you won’t expect.

The Carton Show is breaking down ALL the NFL moves rocking New York! Giants pull off a huge upgrade with Isaiah Likely, Jets go all-in with Minkah Fitzpatrick and more, and Tua Tagovailoa officially heads to Atlanta. Plus, Carson Wentz vs. Geno Smith debates, free agency surprises, and what these moves mean for your favorite team! Don’t miss Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle’s hot takes and listener reactions

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the latest NFL free agency madness! Giants lock in another key piece, but what about the running back situation? Jets fans are losing it over Geno Smith so bad he helped Seattle win a Super Bowl AND gave the Raiders the #1 pick!? Plus, we’ve got the most insane finish in LA Marathon history where an American edges out a Kenyan by 0.01 seconds! Football, controversy, and unbelievable sports moments.

Rock star meets sports talk! On The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle welcome Train frontman Pat Monahan into the WFAN studio for an awesome conversation about music, sports, and one of the biggest songs of the last 25 years.

On WFAN’s Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle are joined by Connor Hughes to break down shocking developments involving the New York Giants and New York Jets.

Things got wild on The Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to a jam-packed sports day. First, Big Mac officially announces the name of his brand-new Yankees podcast — “The Go Get ‘Em Podcast!”

Things got heated on WFAN’s Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to NFL legal tampering day and the chaos of free agency.

The NFL legal tampering window is OPEN and the madness has begun! On The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to a wild day of deals across the league including major moves involving the New York Jets and New York Giants.

Evan & Tiki react to comments from Ron Darling about the Mets rotation and whether or not they should start with a 5- or 6-man rotation. Plus, Evan & Tiki on the contrived Soto Shuffle ‘controversy’ (20:34); Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle revisit the Roger Clemens-Mike Piazza incident with a shocking defense of Clemens (37:17); Boomer & Gio on Freddy Peralta getting the nod for Opening Day.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss whether or not the Knicks have become a better team under Mike Brown vs. Tom Thibodeau. Plus, Craig and C-Mac react to comments from David Fizdale that the team was tanking during his tenure (20:43); Evan and Tiki on how the Knicks play against elite teams (40:02), and their reaction to the loss to the Thunder and the replay factor (55:42); Boomer & Gio react to the Thunder loss (1:13:534) and the Fizdale comments (1:22:48).

With NFL free agency closing in, Craig Carton wonders if the Giants are poised to make major additions in year one under John Harbaugh. Plus, is the noise around the running back position a smokescreen, or could Big Blue really draft Jeremiyah Love at No. 5? Evan wonders if Maxx Crosby could make sense for a blockbuster move, and makes the case for signing Kenneth Walker III.

Is Kyler Murray a fit for the Jets as their next starting quarterback? Boomer and Gio aren't sure he is what Frank Reich is looking for, while Evan Roberts would be open to the addition. Plus, Craig Carton wants NO part of Tua Tagovailoa, and SNY's Connor Hughes gives the latest on the Murray rumors.

After hearing a lot of negative discussion regarding Tua and the Jets, as soon as Carson Wentz's name comes up, somehow Tua sounds like a great option! Chris McMonigle is narrowing names down for his upcoming Yankee Podcast, Hoff is narrowing his wiggle room to flying to and back from Florida in time for Mondays show. Carton takes revenge on both! Some people may think that the Jets have so many choices at quarterback. The real question is, what's the best option? The comparison turns into a Titanic reference which leads into C-Mac's hate for the movie, or the boat, or both! Juan Soto is having a blast at the WBC and the games don't even count yet. Plus, Shohei is the best of the best in all of sports.

After hearing a lot of negative discussion regarding Tua and the Jets, as soon as Carson Wentz's name comes up, somehow Tua sounds like a great option!