The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Things get heated AND hilarious on the Carton Show! Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle debate whether a projected No. 1 overall pick should skip the NFL Draft — is it disrespectful to the league or a personal choice?

raig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle bring the heat in this must-watch segment from the Carton Show on WFAN! From strong takes on the biggest stories in sports to hilarious off-the-rails moments, the guys mix sharp analysis with the kind of unpredictable energy that makes WFAN can’t-miss radio.

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle break down the growing drama surrounding Dexter Lawrence and his reported trade request. Is this a real desire to leave the Giants, or just a negotiating tactic for more guaranteed money?

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle go OFF on the upcoming World Cup madness hitting the New York/New Jersey area. From outrageous $80 NJ Transit tickets to jaw-dropping $75,000-per-night hotel suites, the guys break down what they’re calling massive price gouging ahead of matches at MetLife Stadium.

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle keep the laughs rolling in this chaotic segment of the Carton Show! The guys continue roasting the New York Mets over their game time decision—with jokes flying (including a hilarious parody report about canceling summer games because it’s “too hot” for fans 😅).

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle kick off the show diving into a heated debate: did the New York Mets just disrespect their own fans? After moving their game time due to cold weather, the Mets offered fans replacement tickets but is it really generosity or just the law? Meanwhile, the New York Yankees stand firm, trusting their fans to tough it out in classic April baseball conditions.

Things take a hilarious and completely unexpected turn on the Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle get sidetracked by a very questionable headline. What starts as a simple discussion about a school “mentoring day” quickly spirals into chaos when the phrase “first hand job experience” gets, interpreted a little differently depending on how you say it. With Gallo and the crew jumping in, the segment turns into pure radio gold filled with awkward reads, double entendres, and nonstop laughs. Plus, the guys circle back to Mets vs Yankees fan debates and react to callers dealing with the Citi Field time change.

From ‘Go Get ‘Em’ (Subscribe Here): Chris McMonigle breaks down a Yankees series victory over the Marlins, but cracks have begun to show in the form of the bullpen and the bottom of the order. C-Mac sounds off on the continued struggles of Jose Caballero, Ryan McMahon, and Austin Wells, declaring that the Yanks miss Anthony Volpe given how poorly Caballero has played. He also sounds off on Jazz Chisholm's mental gaffe in game two, and went off on critics of Aaron Boone who didn't like his decisions in the series finale, from the bullpen to pinch hitting J.C. Escarra in the ninth. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

News breaks earlier in the day that Dexter Lawrence is done with the Giants and has requested a trade. In what seemed like a complete 180 with the hire of John Harbaugh a top player on defense wants out even before the draft hits. Plus Mets give updated on Schedule changes and Juan Soto updates. The Mets did the right thing by changing the game time due to weather conditions. Will it make a difference with how many people show up? News of Dexter Lawrence hit the news cycle. We learn more from Pat Leonard and if this trade request is a final ditch effort to get paid or does he really want out from the Giants organization. The Yankees planned for a long wait during Sunday's game as weather was going to be bad all day. However, did they consider what the fans would be doing for 4 hours before first pitch?

News breaks earlier in the day that Dexter Lawrence is done with the Giants and has requested a trade. In what seemed like a complete 180 with the hire of John Harbaugh a top player on defense wants out even before the draft hits. Plus Mets give updated on Schedule changes and Juan Soto updates.

The Mets did the right thing by changing the game time due to weather conditions. Will it make a difference with how many people show up?

News of Dexter Lawrence hit the news cycle. We learn more from Pat Leonard and if this trade request is a final ditch effort to get paid or does he really want out from the Giants organization.

The Yankees planned for a long wait during Sunday's game as weather was going to be bad all day. However, did they consider what the fans would be doing for 4 hours before first pitch?

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down a packed show filled with weather drama, Yankees frustration, and one VERY controversial nickname. The Mets move their start times earlier to help fans deal with brutal cold and wind at Citi Field but did the Yankees handle their 4-hour rain delay the right way?

This Carton Show segment on WFAN delivers one of the funniest calls of the year 🤣 A Yankees fan calls in to complain about his Opening Day experience at Yankee Stadium because he couldn’t find a Heineken, his wife deserves an award!

This segment of The Carton Show on WFAN goes completely off the rails, in the best way possible!

On this hilarious segment of The Carton Show on WFAN, Craig Carton comes clean about a secret trip to Yankee Stadium and it involves one of the craziest ballpark foods ever, fried chicken ice cream!

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle are joined by Pat Leonard to break down the shocking report that Giants star DT Dexter Lawrence could be seeking a trade.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the Mets moving their game times earlier due to weather and whether the Yankees will follow suit or stick to their schedule. Plus, breaking news as Juan Soto lands on the IL and what it means for the Mets moving forward.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into a jam-packed segment on WFAN as the New York Mets make a fan-friendly move, pushing game times earlier due to weather, while the New York Yankees face pressure to follow suit.

Big-time drama in New York sports. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to shocking news involving the New York Giants, as Dexter Lawrence reportedly tells the team he wants OUT.

As the regular season winds down, Evan Roberts raises red flags around the chemistry between Jalen Brunson and Karl-Anthony Towns. Plus, Gio expresses his concerns about the Knicks ahead of the playoffs (25:10), and Evan, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash discuss the potential playoff seeding and matchups (34:08).

Aaron Glenn makes surprises fans with comment that Geno Smith can take the Jets to the ‘Promised Land.’ Hear the best reactions to these comments from Boomer & Gio (0:00), Evan & Tiki (13:18), and Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle (38:34).

Francisco Lindor heard plenty of criticism after his two gaffes in the Mets' series finale against the Cardinals, to the point where Craig Carton called for his tenure in Queens to come to an end. Plus, Evan Roberts says Carlos Mendoza missed an opportunity to send a message and bench the veteran shortstop, and Gregg Giannotti believes the fanbase needs to calm down.

Cam Schlittler was all the hype this week in Yankees Universe, as Evan Roberts declares that the sky is the limit for the Yankee righty, and Gio says Schlittler would fit right in on the 90s dynasty teams. Plus, Tommy Lugauer says Max Fried was worth every penny, Evan and Tiki see a new edge to these Yanks, and Boomer and Gio react to the Bombers' success with the new ABS challenge system.

The Yankees home opener always hits different. Especially when Aaron Judge delivers! Nothing beats a kids first ever opening day. Evan Roberts checks in with C-Mac after a long day at Yankee Stadium ends with a flat tire.

The Yankees home opener always hits different. Especially when Aaron Judge delivers!

Nothing beats a kids first ever opening day.

Evan Roberts checks in with C-Mac after a long day at Yankee Stadium ends with a flat tire.

Things are getting SPICY in New York baseball. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the growing controversy surrounding the New York Mets, including tension involving Francisco Lindor and Brandon Nimmo.

Chris McMonigle react to another Yankees win as the team improves to 6-1 behind dominant pitching and a booming HR from Aaron Judge. But the real story? Evan Roberts joins the show after a BRUTAL experience leaving Yankee Stadium!

The New York Yankees keep rolling to start 2026, and Craig Carton with Chris McMonigle break down a perfect Opening Day in the Bronx!

The New York Yankees are on FIRE to start the 2026 season, and Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break it all down on The Carton Show!

From ‘Go Get ‘Em’ (Subscribe Here): Chris McMonigle breaks down a series win against the Mariners, highlighted by more dominant starting pitching. C-Mac breaks down Cam Schlitter's gem in the series finale, and the concerning return of Camilo Doval's command problems. Plus, the plan for Giancarlo Stanton after a day off, Aaron Boone hitting all the right notes through the first six games, and the struggles of the bottom of the order. Chris also reveals who he is shilling and shaming after the Seattle series. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

After a rough game for Francisco Lindor ,where he not only forgot how many outs there were in the first inning, but also got picked off the base path just before Juan Soto hit a home run. Should Carlos Mendoza prove a point with the 2026 roster by benching Lindor? Deontay Wilder sits down with Piers Morgan and discusses how he came about having a daughter. This may arguably be the best answer in the history of the world. Hold onto your butts! Kirk Cousins continues to shock the world by making more money than any quarterback or player in NFL history. Plus, Cam Schlittler is the best pitcher to ever dawn the pinstripes. Josh Allen is officially a Girl Dad, for now. However, according to some new rules Carton discovers, that may not be the case forever. Plus, can C-Mac have a flawless week with the Wheel?

After a rough game for Francisco Lindor ,where he not only forgot how many outs there were in the first inning, but also got picked off the base path just before Juan Soto hit a home run. Should Carlos Mendoza prove a point with the 2026 roster by benching Lindor?

Deontay Wilder sits down with Piers Morgan and discusses how he came about having a daughter. This may arguably be the best answer in the history of the world. Hold onto your butts!

Kirk Cousins continues to shock the world by making more money than any quarterback or player in NFL history. Plus, Cam Schlittler is the best pitcher to ever dawn the pinstripes.

Josh Allen is officially a Girl Dad, for now. However, according to some new rules Carton discovers, that may not be the case forever. Plus, can C-Mac have a flawless week with the Wheel?

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle put Big Mac and Pete Hoffman to the test with a wild round of Giants first-round draft picks — and it turns into an all-time performance. From Saquon Barkley to Lawrence Taylor, the names keep coming as the pressure builds!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle kick things off by giving away Wu-Tang Clan tickets before diving into a hilarious (and questionable) “men’s night” plan during WFAN’s upcoming NFL Draft broadcast

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into one of the funniest (and most chaotic) debates yet, what actually qualifies as a “girl dad”?!

On this segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down Cousins’ reported deal with the Las Vegas Raiders and debate whether he’s actually worth it.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go OFF on everything from space travel to New York baseball in this wild segment!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle take a hilarious detour from Mets frustration into one of the most random (and funny) debates yet — unread emails, inbox chaos, and whether Big Mac left his account open in the studio

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go OFF on Francisco Lindor after a brutal mental mistake early in the game that had everyone asking: how do you not know how many outs there are?!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open the show with a fiery takedown of Francisco Lindor after a shocking mental lapse in the first inning against the Cardinals.

Carton is furious that the basketball hall of fame elected a bunch of compilers this year. Plus, Giancarlo sits and Yankee fans won't have access to tampons in the mens room. It's the baseball term that most people know when we come to the third game of a split series, the rubber Match. But where does it come from?

Carton is furious that the basketball hall of fame elected a bunch of compilers this year. Plus, Giancarlo sits and Yankee fans won't have access to tampons in the mens room.

It's the baseball term that most people know when we come to the third game of a split series, the rubber Match. But where does it come from?