The Carton Show with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle

Well, a lot of people did. And a lot of people won. Unfortunately, all bets were canceled.

We find out from the extremely stable Shia Labeouf that Mike Piazza was not very good with the autographs. Plus, the Giants are hunting for a new running back.

It's another episode of "Spin That Wheel". They play two rounds. Big Mac vs Hoff and Gallo vs Big Mac. This game is one that will make you yell and scream at the radio.

Mike Piazza stories flow in as we find out not signing autographs is part of Mike's norm. Plus, the biggest unknown in the 2026 MLB season is the New York Mets.

You won’t believe what Big Mac reveals on the Carton Show! From Taylor Dayne’s Long Island roots and Grammy nods, to Knicks’ surprising victories, and a lifetime ban at the Hollywood Hard Rock, nothing is off limits. Plus, Knicks playoff predictions, NBA insights, Mets trade opinions, and a rare Shamrock Shake update. You have to hear this one!

You won’t believe what Craig Carton pulled off LIVE on WFAN! He surprises Chris McMonigle with his first-ever autograph card, a moment 18 years in the making! Plus, listeners share a wild story about Mike Piazza bowling like you’ve never seen, avoiding eye contact with kids, moonwalking, and leaving everyone stunned!

The Carton Show is back with Big Mac, Gallo, and Craig McMonigle in a battle of wits on Spin That Wheel! From athletes who rocked the number 23, to Oscar-winning movies this century, our hosts compete in a hilarious and unpredictable trivia showdown. Who dominates the wheel? Who chokes under pressure? You won’t believe the answers and the epic reactions!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into hilarious and nostalgic stories on the Carton Show! From Chubby Checker opening for Debbie Gibson, to Billy Joel trivia, and the big comedy night at Gotham Comedy Club supporting Saint Jude’s this segment is packed with laughs, memories, and insider chaos. Don’t miss the fun!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive deep into the latest New York Giants chaos! Are the Giants really targeting a running back with their 5th overall pick, or is it all a smokescreen? Plus, Joe Shane’s GM role drama, cap space concerns, and some wild European adventures in Germany, including awkward nightlife stories you won’t believe. Giants fans, this is a must-watch!

All hell breaks loose on The Carton Show after actor Shia LaBeouf calls out Mike Piazza over a childhood autograph snub and it somehow turns into one of the most heated debates in WFAN history.

Things got HEATED on The Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle went off over the latest NFL drama. From shocking front office decisions to what this means for New York sports fans, nothing was held back.

The Carton Show opens with one of the wildest discussions you’ll ever hear — millions of dollars wagered on global events through predictive gambling markets… and when the outcome happens, bettors STILL don’t get paid!

Evan, Tiki & Shaun Morash on the latest power dynamics of the Giants front office. Plus, Shaun and Tiki react to Joe Schoen’s comments from the NFL Combine (21:51); Craig Carton on whether or not Schoen is truly running the show (41:38); Craig on a potential Giants smokescreen with their reported interest in Jeremiah Love (51:40).

Evan & Tiki and Shaun Morash react to the Jets trading Jermaine Johnson to the Titans. Plus, Shaun and Tiki discuss Jets rumors (10:51); Craig Carton on Aaron Glenn’s ‘superpower’ (19:27); Boomer, Gio and Jerry on Glenn receiving an ‘A’ rating from the players (41:20); Boomer & Gio on the Jets’ QB needs (57:06).

As Pete Alonso flexes his power at Orioles spring training, Boomer & Gio wonder if any regret from the Mets will start to sink in. Plus, Evan & Tiki react to comments from Daryl Strawberry who says Alonso will be the one who regrets leaving New York (12:04); Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber on the Mets choosing Freddy Peralta over Nolan McLean to start Opening Day (30:42); a caller asks Evan about Joe Benigno’s anger toward the Mets (54:43)

Karl-Anthony Towns only attempted five shots from the field in an embarrassing loss to the Cavaliers, and Craig Carton wonders if Jalen Brunson deserves more of the blame. Plus, Boomer Esiason points the finger at Mike Brown, wondering if the Knicks made a mistake in firing Tom Thibodeau.

Giancarlo Stanton told NJ.com that it hurts his elbows to simply open a bag of potato chips, and that set off Craig Carton and Shaun Morash, though Chris McMonigle believes it's a nothing story. Plus, all the reaction to the Yanks announcing that they will retire CC Sabathia's number this season.

That's right, Carton thinks that Tom Brady has something up his sleeve again that's going to set the Jets back another decade or more! Emmanuel Berbari gets a blessing from Big Mac on his home run call, plus NBA records are made to be broken. That's right, the Atlanta Hawks are promoting the best place to get wings. Plus, the Mount Rushmore of Cartoons; This will shock you! How does Handicap parking at the World Cup turn into returning your shopping cart? Tune in and you'll find out!

That's right, Carton thinks that Tom Brady has something up his sleeve again that's going to set the Jets back another decade or more!

Emmanuel Berbari gets a blessing from Big Mac on his home run call, plus NBA records are made to be broken.

That's right, the Atlanta Hawks are promoting the best place to get wings. Plus, the Mount Rushmore of Cartoons; This will shock you!

How does Handicap parking at the World Cup turn into returning your shopping cart? Tune in and you'll find out!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive deep into the wildest NFL drama: could Tom Brady’s latest draft moves secretly set up the Jets for disaster—or a miracle? Plus, hilarious takes on Magic City night, legendary wings, and cocktail hour must-haves. From Brady’s “lentil soup theft” to fantasy draft nightmares, nothing is off-limits in this chaotic, laugh-out-loud segment!

You won’t believe what happened at the NFL Combine! New York Jets head coach Aaron Glenn was caught dozing off yes, DOZING for a few seconds on live camera, and the Carton Show breaks down every hilarious detail. From comparisons to viral state-of-the-Union naps to how the Jets could lean into it with pajamas and sleep masks, Craig Carton and Big Mac dissect the chaos. Plus, we dive into Yankees spring training drama, signature home run calls, and unforgettable music debates! It's everything you didn’t know you needed today!

Chris McMonigle and Craig Carton break down one of the most insane NBA moments you’ll ever see, Trace Jackson-Davis grabs a rebound in 0.3 seconds and becomes the “greatest rebounder in history”! Plus, the duo dives deep into the New York Jets draft drama, debating Mendoza vs. Ty Simpson and even calling out a “sleepy coach” scandal. Also, Yankees signature home run calls, shocking international basketball losses, and more! You won’t want to miss these hot takes from WFAN’s Carton Show.

Absolute Jets paranoia is reaching new levels

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go OFF on the biggest parking lot pet peeve: people leaving shopping carts everywhere! From why it shows your true character, to how it impacts the employees doing the real work, this heated discussion is full of laughs, wild opinions, and even some Super Bowl snack secrets—mini grilled cheese and tomato soup, anyone? Plus, we break down the rarest football scoring play you’ve probably never heard of: the ONE POINT SAFETY!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the viral story that has fans stunned plus they circle back to the never-ending chaos surrounding the New York Jets and the looming draft nightmare involving Tom Brady and the Las Vegas Raiders.

Total chaos for the New York Jets! After a rare moment of optimism, everything spirals when head coach Aaron Glenn is caught snoozing at the NFL Combine and the embarrassment goes viral.

CC Sabathia is a no doubt hall of famer and a no doubt number that needs to be retired by the Yankees. Plus, what is wrong with Giancarlo Stanton's elbows??? No matter how banged up Stanton is, if he plays in 70 games, those 70 games are more productive than most players who play in 162. Matt Waldron has a very bad infection in an area where not many have the experience to speak about. Craig Carton is the rare person who can relate. Woody Johnson tried hard to stop the NFL grades from coming out. It didn't work. Somehow, Woody is lucky they DID come out!

CC Sabathia is a no doubt hall of famer and a no doubt number that needs to be retired by the Yankees. Plus, what is wrong with Giancarlo Stanton's elbows???

No matter how banged up Stanton is, if he plays in 70 games, those 70 games are more productive than most players who play in 162.

Matt Waldron has a very bad infection in an area where not many have the experience to speak about. Craig Carton is the rare person who can relate.

Woody Johnson tried hard to stop the NFL grades from coming out. It didn't work. Somehow, Woody is lucky they DID come out!

On today’s Carton Show with Chris McMonigle and Craig Carton, the conversation gets fiery and hilarious! Craig calls out Tony Dungy’s 17-year broadcasting snooze-fest, debates Giancarlo Stanton’s elbow strategy, and lays down the law on the ultimate pet peeve: air sports. Plus, dogs, curling, and fan calls add to the chaos you won’t believe what happens next!

In this eye-opening segment of the Carton Show with Craig Carton and Big Mac, we dive into the newly released NFL player grades for coaches, GMs, and owners. The Jets’ Aaron Glenn and Woody Johnson get stellar marks despite a tough season, while the Giants’ leadership continues to face criticism. We also break down ratings for every major team, including the Bills, Patriots, Steelers, and more. Are these grades meaningful or just perception? Tune in and find out!

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into one of the most awkward sports stories yet, Giancarlo Stanton, Cody Bellinger, and the woman who connects them both! From bench press videos to embarrassing single-life moments, this WFAN segment spills the tea on what happens when past relationships collide with pro athletes’ lives. Plus, they discuss punters, Australian NFL talent, and “the way of the dodo” you don’t want to miss this wild ride!

On today’s Carton Show with Chris McMonigle and Craig Carton, things get wild! Craig shares his painful hemorrhoidectomy experience, including adult diapers, a plane ride from hell, and an unforgettable encounter with Bill Belichick. Plus, we dive into the Jets’ surprising trade, Giancarlo Stanton’s elbow issues, and crazy fan calls that will make you laugh, cringe, and say… “No way!” Don’t miss this unforgettable mix of sports, pain, and hilarity!

On this explosive segment of The Carton Show with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle, the hosts break down one of the most shocking games in college basketball history! Saint John's, a top 15 team in America, managed to go 17 and a half minutes without a single basket in the second half against UConn, losing by a staggering 32 points. The disastrous performance sparked a conversation about team chemistry, Pitino’s coaching, and how even a breakfast tweet might have foreshadowed this meltdown.