True Crime Society

In two separate but similar incidents, Alan White and & Jake Cefolia were both last seen on surveillance pumping gas before each of their luxury vehicles were found abandoned in vacant areas. After months of searching, neither man has been found and clues to their disappearance are limited. While some have speculated that either man could have left to start a new life, others fear something much more sinister may have happened to them. Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

When someone is reported missing, it's generally safe to assume they're not in their house. Surely, the police or the family would have checked there already. Except sometimes, after the headlines, the search parties, and the emotional public pleas from family members - that's exactly where the person turns up. In this episode, we cover a handful of cases where this phenomenon happened and the theories surrounding them. Julie Snyder, Molly Meghan Miller, and Christopher Woitel were all found dead in their homes after being reported missing and searched for. Don't want to listen to the intro? The episode begins around 15 minutes in. Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

We're back to let you know why we hate Facebook and to fill you in on everything that happened while we were on break. This includes, the murder of influencer Alexis Sharkey, the disappearance of Jason Landry, and the identification of Mostly Harmless. Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

A mother is meant to be the ultimate protector of their children. Sometimes though, they are perpetrators of the ultimate betrayal.In this episode we speak about four cases where mothers have taken the lives of their children, before killing themselves. What could drive a woman to the edge like this?1 – Michele Boudreau Deegan drugged her twin 7 y/o daughters before shooting them and then herself in the head2 – Cynthia Collier fired 34 rounds into her four adopted teenage children, before taking her own life3 – Kimbra Shanafelt and her 5 y/o daughter were found dead in their home from carbon monoxide poisoning4 – Tristen Watson was pregnant when she took her toddler son into the Rocky Mountains National Park. She shot him and then herself, and her unborn baby also passed away.Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

... or maybe you'll want to visit? We wont judge. In honor of Halloween, we discuss three famous (and possibly haunted) murder houses - the Villisca axe murders house, the Los Feliz murder mansion, and the Sowden house and it's possible connection to the Black Dahlia. Would you ever live in one of these houses? Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

With surveillance cameras becoming more and more accessible, it makes sense that more and more crimes are being caught on camera. In this episode we talk about four crimes that were caught on camera - the Watts family murders, the murder of Elizabeth Barraza, missing Leila Cavett, and the mysterious death of Elisa Lam. Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

In this episode we go over all the updates (and non-updates) to the cases we've covered so far with the award for BIGGEST update going to the Michael Shaver case (finally!!) Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

15-month-old Evelyn Boswell was reported missing on February 19th, 2020 by her grandfather, but she hadn't actually been seen since December 2019.I'm sure you're wondering - how does a missing baby go unreported for 2 months?Her mother, 18-year-old Megan Boswell, tried to explain during an interview, "Well, the reason I didn’t report it or anything was I knew the person who had her and I didn’t want them to run away with her. In a way, I knew that as soon as anything went down this person was going to disappear and they have."A month later, Evelyn's remains were found in a shed on a family member's property with her toys, clothes, and diapers. With a family full of felons pointing fingers at each other, investigators had a long road ahead of them - but ultimately they were able to make an arrest.Story beings @ 14:45Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

Finding a body in a suitcase is a typical true crime cliche - but how often does it really happen and what circumstances prompt someone to hide a body in a suitcase? In this episode, we discuss the cases of Jessica Lewis & Austin Wenner, Karlie Pearce-Stevenson and her daughter Khandalyce, and Valerie Reyes - all homicide victims whose remains were found in suitcases.Check out our website for more information on these cases and our sources.Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

The last known sighting of Michael Shaver was in November 2015. It took over two years for friends and family to realize he was missing because someone was responding to his messages and updating his social media pretending to be him. He didn't seem like himself and in February 2018 a friend called for a wellness check on him. Police went to his home and found his wife, Laurie Shaver, who told police she hadn't seen him for years. Well, a few months later police found Michael Shaver's body buried under a cement fire pit in the backyard of the home he once shared with Laurie. As cut & dry as this case seems, it still remains unsolved. Story Begins: 18:52 Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

While hiking in Big Cypress National Preserve, two friends stumbled upon an emaciated man's remains in a tent along the trail. The man had no identification, no cell phone, no bank cards and didn't come up in any of the police's databases. After releasing a composite sketch of the man, a handful of fellow hikers, hostel proprietors and trail angels came forward saying they met this man along his journey from NY to FL. They knew stories about him and even had photos of him, but they only knew him as "Denim" or "Mostly Harmless" - his trail names. It seemed like no one knew his true identity and that was they way he wanted it. It's been 2 years since Mostly Harmless's remains were found in July 2017 and he has yet to be identified. The Collier County Sheriff's Office hasn't given up and is pursuing genealogy testing in hopes to locate a relative. But, if Mostly Harmless went to such great lengths to conceal his identity, do we have the right to identify him? Check out our blog for more information, photos, and the sources used for this episode. Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

To anyone looking in, the Todts seemed like the perfect family. Megan and Tony Todt, both successful physical therapists, lived in Celebration, Florida - a picturesque community created by the Walt Disney Company, with their three children. While the family could be seen smiling in matching Christmas pajamas on social media - a dark secret loomed over them. Unbeknownst to Megan, Tony was being federally investigated for committing health insurance fraud to cover their astronomical debt. In December 2019, Tony (*allegedly*) snapped and murdered Megan, their children and even their family dog. He then remained inside their home with the bodies for days creating a web of lies to cover his tracks. Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

On April 13th, 2011, 20-year-old Holly Bobo spent her morning studying for an exam she'd never take. She'd pack her things, grab her lunch and walk out the door - only to cross paths with a strange man dressed in camouflage. Holly was last seen by her brother, who caught a glimpse of her through the window, walking into the woods with who he thought was her boyfriend. From there, what happened to Holly would remain a mystery for nearly 6 years. A handful of men were arrested for Holly's abduction, rape and murder, but not everyone believes the right men are behind bars. In this episode, we go over what happened at Zach Adams' murder trial and discuss other theories as to what may have happened to Holly. Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

On April 13th, 2011, 20-year-old Holly Bobo spent her morning studying for an exam she'd never take. She'd pack her things, grab her lunch and walk out the door - only to cross paths with a strange man dressed in camouflage. Holly was last seen by her brother, who caught a glimpse of her through the window, walking into the woods with who he thought was her boyfriend. From there, what happened to Holly would remain a mystery for nearly 6 years.Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

This is a mini episode because OF COURSE Chad Daybell's arrest affidavit was released RIGHT AFTER we published our previous episode. So, here are the latest updates from the affidavit which gives us a bit more insight into what may have happened to Tylee and JJ last September.Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

If you're not familiar with this case, we've got you covered. Between the zombies, gods, missing children, and multiple dead spouses - it can be hard to keep up. In this episode, we go over ALL the details to date pertaining to the strange case of Lori Vallow and her fifth husband, Chad Daybell. Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

70% of murder-suicides involve an intimate partner - a husband and wife, a boyfriend and girlfriend, etc. In March 2019, police officer Bailey Smith shot and killed his cousin Emeri Connery before turning the gun on himself. The two were driving home after a long night celebrating Bailey's 21st birthday. Strangely, Bailey was memorialized by the community with parades and celebrations, while Emeri, the actual victim of the crime, was hardly mentioned at all. Even Emeri's family seemed to defend her killer. So, do they know something we don't? In this episode, we talk briefly about updates in the Madeleine McCann case before diving into what happened between Bailey and Emeri that night and murder-suicides in general. Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

In this episode we have a few quick updates on Corinna Slusser, Madison Bell, and Maura Murray. The bulk of the episode is about Tyler Davis & Chance Englebert who separately vanished in 2019 and their stories have a lot of similarities. Tyler Davis vanished after walking away from his Ohio hotel after a night celebrating his wife's birthday. While Chance Engelbert walked away from his wife's grandparent's home after an argument. There has been no sign of either man, leaving their family with no closure. What happened to them? Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

The months before Corinna Slusser turned 19 were rocky, to say the least. It was 2017, she wasn’t getting along with her mom, she dropped out of high school right before graduation and she had a failed suicide attempt that landed her in the hospital. While she was in the hospital, she met a man who would ultimately change the course of her life forever. Corinna left all of her belongings behind. Taking only the clothes she was wearing, her phone and her ID, she headed to New York City in August 2017 with this man to follow her dreams. Corinna began escorting and working for various pimps before she vanished completely in September, 2017. Those who saw her last are quick to say she ran off, but police believe something much more sinister happened and that she became a victim of human trafficking. In this episode we discuss Corinna's disappearance and the prevalence of sex trafficking in the USA. We also chat about the news that has had us all gripped this week - the cases of runaway teen Madison Bell and the shocking murder of Alejandro Ripley. Be sure to check out our blog for a timeline of Corinna’s disappearance plus screenshots of now deleted social media from those involved. Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

In December 2017, billionaire Apotex founder Barry Sherman and his wife, Honey, were found hung with belts by the indoor pool in their 7 million dollar home. The bodies were semi-seated and posed similarly to a pair of sculptures the Shermans owned. Toronto PD came to the conclusion this was a targeted double murder, but almost 3 years later their killer remains unknown. Story begins at (13:15)Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

In this episode we finish talking about the Long Island Serial Killer. We go over popular suspects and theories while deciding which ones we think are most likely. Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

The Long Island Serial Killer story will be split into TWO episodes because there is A LOT to go over. In this episode we cover the disappearance of Shannan Gilbert and the other potential victims of LISK. At the end, we share our thoughts and theories so far. Next week we will go over the potential suspects, the newest evidence and the Lost Girls Netflix movie. Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)

In this episode we cover the story of Kara Kopetsky and Jessica Runions - who were both allegedly murdered by Kylr Yust. Kara had already been missing for a decade by the time Jessica disappeared, but both girls' remains were found within 30 yards of each other. Be sure to join our Facebook Group if you haven't, just search True Crime Society. Support the show (https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/TrueCrimeSociety)