Episode 19

#19 – Peter Singer on Speciesism, Lockdown Ethics, and Controversial Ideas

Hear This Idea · Fin Moorhouse and Luca Righetti

December 7, 202059m 17s

Audio is streamed directly from the publisher (pinecast.com) as published in their RSS feed. Play Podcasts does not host this file. Rights-holders can request removal through the copyright & takedown page.

Original episode page

Show Notes

Peter Singer is a moral philosopher and public intellectual, most widely known for his writings about animal ethics and global poverty.

In this episode we discuss:

[00:00:00] Introduction
[00:01:43] Background — Peter Singer introduces himself.
[00:02:16] Speciesism — Defining the term, and explaining the case against speciesism.
[00:06:55] Wild Animal Suffering — hould we intervene to reduce suffering in nature?
[00:09:00] Weighing and Ending Animal Lives — Are all animal lives equal? What, if anything, is wrong with (painlessly) killing animals?
[00:13:20] Ignoring Animals: Why did thinkers of the past apparently neglect the moral worth of animals? Why is animal ethics relatively new?
[00:16:50] History of Western Attitudes to Animals—Can we trace the origins of contemporary attitudes to animals back to ancient Greece and Judeo-Christian values?
[00:21:07] Counterfactual Impact of Animal Advocacy
[00:24:10] The Power of Moral Argument
[00:25:00] The Schwitzgebel Study
[00:29:30] What should we do now? — Are veganism and vegetarianism all-or-nothing decisions? Or is it worth choosing a more incremental pathway?
[00:32:25] The case for Human Challenge Trials
[00:35:46] Trade-off between Lives and Well-being in Lockdowns — Can the cure for the pandemic be worse than the disease? How would we know?
[00:42:07] Moral Realism — Parfit's 'Future Tuesday Indifference'
[00:46:10] Other Moral Systems — What about egalitarianism or prioritarianism?
[00:49:10] Controversial ideas
[00:52:28] Journal of Controversial Ideas
[00:54:35] What have you changed your mind about?
[00:55:57] Book Recommendations
[00:57:18] Where to Find PS Online

You can read much more on these topics in our accompanying write-up: https://hearthisidea.com/episodes/peter.

If you have any feedback or suggestions for future guests, please get in touch through our website. Please also consider leaving us a review wherever you're listening to this. If you want to support the show more directly and help us keep hosting these episodes online, consider leaving a tip at www.tips.pinecast.com/jar/hear-this-idea. Thanks for listening!

← All episodes of Hear This Idea