PLAY PODCASTS
Chaos Computer Club - recent events feed

Chaos Computer Club - recent events feed

4,903 episodes — Page 44 of 99

From Silicon to Darude Sand-storm: breaking famous synthesizer DSPs (39c3)

Dec 27, 202539 min

Building a NOC from scratch (39c3)

Learn from our mistakes during the first iteration of Network Operations for Europe's largest furry convention, Eurofurence. Dieses Jahr hat ein kleines Team aus dem Chaos, Furries und Chaos-Furries ein neues Netzwerk-OC gegründet, um die Eurofurence mit gutem premium 👌 Internetz auszustatten. Wir erzählen von unseren Erfahrungen und den sozialen sowie technischen Herausforderungen. Zum Zeitpunkt der 29. Eurofurence (also dieses Jahr) hatte das Event eine Größe erreicht, bei der typische Event-Locations unsere speziellen Anforderungen nicht mal eben so erfüllen konnten. Beispielsweise ist eine aufwändige Audio/Video-Produktion Teil der Eurofurence, welche ein IP-Netz mit hoher Bandbreite, niederiger Latenz, niedrigem Jitter, Multicast-Transport und präzise Zeitsynchronisierung benötigt. Deshalb wurde dieses Jahr das _Onsite Eurofurence Network Operation Center_ _(EFNOC)_ gegründet. Unsere Aufgabe sollte es sein, alle Anforderungen der anderen Teams kompetent zu erfüllen wovon wir euch in diesem Vortrag etwas aus dem Nähkästchen erzählen wollen. Grob haben wir wärend der EF29 das Team etabliert und ein Netzwerk gebaut, welches für A/V-Produktion, Event-Koordination und Event-Management (z.B. Security, Ticketing) benutzt wurde. Unser persönliches Ziel war es außerdem, ein benutzbares WLAN-Netzwerk für alle Besuchenden über dies gesamte Event-Venue hinweg zu schaffen – also von Halle H bis zum Vorplatz. Unsere Architektur bestand dafür aus einem simplen Layer2-Netzwerk mit VLAN-Unterteilung, welches von _Arista DCS-7050TX-72Q_ mit 40Gbit/s Optiken bereitgestellt wurde. Die Aristas haben außerdem ein PTP-Signal propagiert, welches von einer Meinberg Master-Clock gesteuert wurde. Zusätzlich war ein Linux-Server als Hypervisor für diverse Netzwerk-Services wie DNS, DHCP, Monitoring und Routing im Einsatz. So zumindest der Plan, denn während des Events wurden wir mit der Realität und vielen „spaßigen“ Problemen konfrontiert. Unser Talk wird sich unter anderem mit diesen technischen Problemen beschäftigen, allerdings den Fokus nicht nur auf die technische Darstellung legen. Stattdessen werden wir auch beleuchten, wie wir als Team menschlich untereinander und in der Kommunikation mit anderen Teams damit umgegangen sind. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/building-a-noc-from-scratch

Dec 27, 202534 min

From Silicon to Darude Sand-storm: breaking famous synthesizer DSPs (39c3)

Have you ever wondered how the chips and algorithms that made all those electronic music hits work? Us too! At The Usual Suspects we create open source emulations of famous music hardware, synthesizers and effect units. After releasing some emulations of devices around the Motorola 563xx DSP chip, we made further steps into reverse engineering custom silicon chips to achieve what no one has done before: a real low-level emulation of the JP-8000. This famous synthesizer featured a special "SuperSaw" oscillator algorithm, which defined an entire generation of electronic and trance music. The main obstacle was emulating the 4 custom DSP chips the device used, which ran software written with a completely undocumented instruction set. In this talk I will go through the story of how we overcame that obstacle, using a mixture of automated silicon reverse engineering, probing the chip with an Arduino, statistical analysis of the opcodes and fuzzing. Finally, I will talk about how we made the emulator run in real-time using JIT, and what we found by looking at the SuperSaw code. This talk is a sequel to my last year's talk "Proprietary silicon ICs and dubious marketing claims? Let's fight those with a microscope!", where I showed how I reverse engineered a pretty old device (1986) by looking at microscope silicon pics alone, with manual tracing and some custom tools. Back then I claimed that taking a look at a more modern device would be way more challenging, due to the increased complexity. This time, in fact, I've reverse engineered a much modern chip: the custom Roland/Toshiba TC170C140 ESP chip (1995). Completing this task required a different approach, as doing it manually would have required too much time. We used a guided automated approach that combines clever microscopy with computer vision to automatically classify standard cells in the chip, saving us most of the manual work. The biggest win though came from directly probing the chip: by exploiting test routines and sending random data to the chip we figured out how the internal registers worked, slowly giving us insights about the encoding of the chip ISA. By combining those two approaches we managed to create a bit-accurate emulator, that also is able to run in real-time using JIT. In this talk I want to cover the following topics: - What I learned since my previous talk by looking at more complicated chips - Towards automating the silicon reverse engineering process - How to find and exploit test modes to understand how stuff works - How we tricked the chips into spilling its own secrets - How the ESP chip works, compared to existing DSP chips - How the SuperSaw oscillator turned out to work Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/from-silicon-to-darude-sand-storm-breaking-famous-synthesizer-dsps

Dec 27, 202539 min

Bluetooth Headphone Jacking: A Key to Your Phone (39c3)

Dec 27, 202559 min

Breaking architecture barriers: Running x86 games and apps on ARM (39c3)

Dec 27, 202538 min

Coding Dissent: Art, Technology, and Tactical Media (39c3)

Dec 27, 202538 min

Breaking architecture barriers: Running x86 games and apps on ARM (39c3)

Presenting FEX, a translation layer to run x86 apps and games on ARM devices: Learn why x86 is such a pain to emulate, what tricks and techniques make your games fly with minimal translation overhead, and how we are seamless enough that you'll forget what CPU you're using in the first place! ARM-powered hardware in laptops promises longer battery life at the same compute performance as before, but a translation layer like FEX is needed to run existing x86 software. We'll look at the technical challenges involved in making this possible: designing a high-performance binary recompiler, translating Linux system calls across architectures, and forwarding library calls to their ARM counterparts. Gaming in particular poses extreme demands on FEX and raises further questions: How do we enable GPU acceleration in an emulated environment? How can we integrate Wine to run Windows games on Linux ARM? Why is Steam itself the ultimate boss battle for x86 emulation? And why in the world do we care more about page sizes than German standardization institutes? This talk will be accessible to a technical audience and gaming enthusiasts alike. However, be prepared to learn cursed knowledge you won't be able to forget! Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/breaking-architecture-barriers-running-x86-games-and-apps-on-arm

Dec 27, 202538 min

Coding Dissent: Art, Technology, and Tactical Media (39c3)

This presentation examines artistic practices that engage with sociotechnical systems through tactical interventions. The talk proposes art as a form of infrastructural critique and counter-technology. It also introduces a forthcoming HackLab designed to foster collaborative development of open-source tools addressing digital authoritarianism, surveillance capitalism, propaganda infrastructures, and ideological warfare. In this talk, media artist and curator Helena Nikonole presents her work at the intersection of art, activism, and tactical technology — including interventions into surveillance systems, wearable mesh networks for off-grid communication, and AI-generated propaganda sabotage. Featuring projects like Antiwar AI, the 868labs initiative, and the curatorial project Digital Resistance, the talk explores how art can do more than just comment on sociotechnical systems — it can interfere, infiltrate, and subvert them. This is about prototypes as politics, networked interventions as civil disobedience, and media hacks as tools of strategic refusal. The talk asks: what happens when art stops decorating crisis and starts debugging it? The talk will also introduce an upcoming HackLab initiative — a collaboration-in-progress that brings together artists, hackers, and activists to develop open-source tools for disruption, resilience, and collective agency — and invites potential collaborators to get involved. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/coding-dissent-art-technology-and-tactical-media

Dec 27, 202538 min

The Eyes of Photon Science: Imaging, Simulation and the Quest to Make the Invisible Visible (39c3)

Science advances by extending our senses beyond the limits of human perception, pushing the boundaries of what we can observe. In photon science, imaging detectors serve as the eyes of science, translating invisible processes into measurable and analysable data. Behind every image lies a deep understanding of how detectors see, respond and perform. At facilities like the European XFEL, the world's most powerful X-ray free-electron laser located in the Hamburg metropolitan area, imaging detectors capture ultrashort X-ray flashes at MHz frame rates and with high dynamic range. Without these advanced detectors, even the brightest X-ray laser beam would remain invisible. They help to reveal what would otherwise stay hidden, such as the structure of biomolecules, the behaviour of novel materials, and matter under extreme conditions. But how do we know they will perform as expected? And how do we design systems capable of “seeing” the invisible? I will take a closer look how imaging technology in large-scale facilities is simulated and designed to make the invisible visible. From predicting detector performance to evaluating image quality, we look at how performance simulation helps scientists and engineers understand the “eyes” of modern science. X-ray imaging detectors have come a long way in the last 15 years, turning ideas that once seemed impossible into realities. Imaging detectors in photon science are more than just high-speed cameras. They are complex systems operating at the limits of what’s physically measurable. Understanding how they behave before, during, and after experiments is essential to advancing both the technology and the science it enables. In this talk, I’ll take you inside the world of detector simulation and performance modelling. I’ll explore how tools like Monte Carlo simulations, sensor response models, and system-level performance evaluations are used to: - Predict detector behaviour in extreme conditions (such as MHz X-ray bursts), and - identify critical performance bottlenecks before production. By linking imaging technology with simulation and modelling, we can better interpret experimental data and design the next generation of scientific cameras. Beyond the technical aspects, this talk reflects on the broader theme of how we “see” though technology, what it means to make the invisible visible, and how simulation changes not only how we build instruments, but also how we understand them. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/the-eyes-of-photon-science-imaging-simulation-and-the-quest-to-make-the-invisible-visible

Dec 27, 202539 min

Bluetooth Headphone Jacking: A Key to Your Phone (39c3)

Bluetooth headphones and earbuds are everywhere, and we were wondering what attackers could abuse them for. Sure, they can probably do things like finding out what the person is currently listening to. But what else? During our research we discovered three vulnerabilities (CVE-2025-20700, CVE-2025-20701, CVE-2025-20702) in popular Bluetooth audio chips developed by Airoha. These chips are used by many popular device manufacturers in numerous Bluetooth headphones and earbuds. The identified vulnerabilities may allow a complete device compromise. We demonstrate the immediate impact using a pair of current-generation headphones. We also demonstrate how a compromised Bluetooth peripheral can be abused to attack paired devices, like smartphones, due to their trust relationship with the peripheral. This presentation will give an overview over the vulnerabilities and a demonstration and discussion of their impact. We also generalize these findings and discuss the impact of compromised Bluetooth peripherals in general. At the end, we briefly discuss the difficulties in the disclosure and patching process. Along with the talk, we will release tooling for users to check whether their devices are affected and for other researchers to continue looking into Airoha-based devices. Examples of affected vendors and devices are Sony (e.g., WH1000-XM5, WH1000-XM6, WF-1000XM5), Marshall (e.g. Major V, Minor IV), Beyerdynamic (e.g. AMIRON 300), or Jabra (e.g. Elite 8 Active). Airoha is a vendor that, amongst other things, builds Bluetooth SoCs and offers reference designs and implementations incorporating these chips. They have become a large supplier in the Bluetooth audio space, especially in the area of True Wireless Stereo (TWS) earbuds. Several reputable headphone and earbud vendors have built products based on Airoha’s SoCs and reference implementations using Airoha’s Software Development Kit (SDK). During our Bluetooth Auracast research we stumbled upon a pair of these headphones. During the process of obtaining the firmware for further research we initially discovered the powerful custom Bluetooth protocol called *RACE*. The protocol provides functionality to take full control of headphones. Data can be written to and read from the device's flash and RAM. The goal of this presentation is twofold. Firstly, we want to inform about the vulnerabilities. It is important that headphone users are aware of the issues. In our opinion, some of the device manufacturers have done a bad job of informing their users about the potential threats and the available security updates. We also want to provide the technical details to understand the issues and enable other researchers to continue working with the platform. With the protocol it is possible to read and write firmware. This opens up the possibility to patch and potentially customize the firmware. Secondly, we want to discuss the general implications of compromising Bluetooth peripherals. As smart phones are becoming increasingly secure, the focus for attackers might shift to other devices in the environment of the smart phone. For example, when the Bluetooth Link Key, that authenticates a Bluetooth connection between the smart phone and the peripheral is stolen, an attacker might be able to impersonate the peripheral and gain its capabilities. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/bluetooth-headphone-jacking-a-key-to-your-phone

Dec 27, 202559 min

DNGerousLINK (39c3)

The spyware attack targeting WhatsApp, disclosed in August as an in-the-wild exploit, garnered significant attention. By simply knowing a victim's phone number, an attacker could launch a remote, zero-interaction attack against the WhatsApp application on Apple devices, including iPhones, iPads, and Macs. Subsequent reports indicated that WhatsApp on Samsung devices was also targeted by similar exploits. In this presentation, we will share our in-depth analysis of this attack, deconstructing the 0-click exploit chain built upon two core vulnerabilities: CVE-2025-55177 and CVE-2025-43300. We will demonstrate how attackers chained these vulnerabilities to remotely compromise WhatsApp and the underlying iOS system without any user interaction or awareness. Following our analysis, we successfully reproduced the exploit chain and constructed an effective PoC capable of simultaneously crashing the target application on iPhones, iPads, and Macs. Finally, we will present our analysis of related vulnerabilities affecting Samsung devices (such as CVE-2025-21043) and share how this investigation led us to discover additional, previously unknown 0-day vulnerabilities. In August 2025, it attracted significant attention when Apple patched CVE-2025-43300, a vulnerability reportedly exploited in-the-wild to execute "extremely sophisticated attack against specific targeted individuals”. A week later, WhatsApp issued a security advisory, revealing the fix for a critical vulnerability, CVE-2025-55177, which was also exploited in-the-wild. Strong evidence indicated that these two vulnerabilities were chained together, enabling attackers to deliver a malicious exploit via WhatsApp to steal data from a user's Apple device, all without any user interaction. To deconstruct this critical and stealthy in-the-wild 0-click exploit chain, we will detail our findings in several parts: 1. WhatsApp 0-Click Attack Vector (CVE-2025-55177). We will describe the 0-click attack surface we identified within WhatsApp. We will detail the flaws in WhatsApp's message handling logic for "linked devices," which stemmed from insufficient validation, and demonstrate how an attacker could craft malicious protocol messages to trigger the vulnerable code path. 2. iOS Image Parsing Vulnerability (CVE-2025-43300). The initial exploit allows an attacker to force the target's WhatsApp to load arbitrary web content. We will then explain how the attacker leverages this by embedding a malicious DNG image within a webpage to trigger a vulnerability in the iOS image parsing library. We will analyze how the RawCamera framework handles the parsing of DNG images, and pinpoint the resulting OOB vulnerability. 3. Rebuilding the Chain: From Vulnerability to PoC. In addition, we will then walk through our process of chaining these two vulnerabilities, constructing a functional Proof-of-Concept (PoC) that can simultaneously crash the WhatsApp application on target iPhones, iPads, and Macs. Beyond Apple: The Samsung Connection (CVE-2025-21043). Samsung's September security bulletin patched CVE-2025-21043, an out-of-bounds write vulnerability in an image parsing library reported by the Meta and WhatsApp security teams. This vulnerability was also confirmed to be exploited in-the-wild. While an official WhatsApp exploit chain for Samsung devices has not been publicly detailed, we will disclose our findings on this related attack. Finally, we will share some unexpected findings from our investigation, including the discovery of several additional, previously undisclosed 0-day vulnerabilities. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/dngerouslink-a-deep-dive-into-whatsapp-0-click-exploits-on-ios-and-samsung-devices

Dec 27, 202552 min

Hacking washing machines (39c3)

Almost everyone has a household appliance at home, whether it's a washing machine, dishwasher, or dryer. Despite their ubiquity, little is publicly documented about how these devices actually work or how their internal components communicate. This talk takes a closer look at proprietary bus systems, hidden diagnostic interfaces, and approaches to cloud-less integration of appliances from two well-known manufacturers into modern home automation systems. Modern home appliances may seem simple from the outside, but inside they contain complex electronic systems, proprietary communication protocols, and diagnostic interfaces rarely documented outside the manufacturer. In this talk, we'll explore the challenges of reverse-engineering these systems: from analyzing appliance control boards and internal communication buses to decompiling and modifying firmware to better understand device functionality. We'll also look at the security mechanisms designed to protect diagnostic access and firmware readout, and how these protections can be bypassed to enable deeper insight into device operation. Finally, this talk will demonstrate how the results of this research can be used to integrate even legacy home appliances into popular home automation platforms. This session combines examples and insights from the reverse-engineering of B/S/H/ and Miele household appliances. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/hacking-washing-machines

Dec 27, 202556 min

Hacking washing machines (39c3)

Dec 27, 202556 min

DNGerousLINK (39c3)

Dec 27, 202552 min

Doomsday-Porn, Schäferhunde und die „niedliche Abschiebung“ von nebenan (39c3)

Dec 27, 20251h 0m

Doomsday-Porn, Schäferhunde und die „niedliche Abschiebung“ von nebenan (39c3)

Der amtierende US-Präsident postet ein Video, in dem er Demonstrierende aus einem Kampfjet heraus mit Fäkalien bewirft und das Weiße Haus zelebriert den „Star Wars Day“ mit einem pompösen Trump-Bild mit Lichtschwert. Accounts von AfD-Sympathisanten posten KI-Kitsch einer vermeintlich heilen Welt voller blonder Kinder und Frauen im Dirndl. Ist das lediglich eine geschmackliche Entgleisung oder steckt da mehr dahinter? KI-generierter Content ist aus der Kommunikationsstrategie autoritärer Akteure nicht mehr wegzudenken. Social Media wird derzeit mit rechtem KI-Slop geflutet, in dem wahlweise die Welt dank Migration kurz vor dem Abgrund steht oder blonde, weiße Familien fröhlich Fahnen schwenken. Im politischen Vorfeld der extremen Rechten werden zudem immer häufiger mal mehr oder weniger offensichtliche Deepfakes geteilt, die auf die jeweilige politische Botschaft einzahlen. Das reicht von KI-generierten Straßenumfragen über Ausschnitte aus Talksendungen, die nie stattgefunden haben, bis hin zu gänzlich KI-generierten Influencerinnen (natürlich blond). Was macht das mit politischen Debatten? Und wie sollten wir als Gesellschaft damit umgehen? Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/radikalisierungspipeline-esoterik-von-eso-nazis-de

Dec 27, 20251h 0m

Throwing your rights under the Omnibus (39c3)

A spectre is haunting Europe—the spectre of bureaucracy. All the Powers of old Europe have entered into an unholy alliance to exorcise this spectre: The EU Commission, Member States, industry, even J.D. Vance. This threatens the digital rights and rules built up in the last decade. The new EU Commission has an agenda. What started with the report of former European Central Bank chief Mario Draghi on Europe's "competitiveness" has quickly turned into "getting rid of bureaucracy", then into "simplification", and finally open "deregulation". What this means is that a large number of European laws that were adopted in the last decade to ensure sustanabiliy, protect human rights along the whole supply chain, or to ensure our digital rights, are watered down, and core elements are scrapped. In terms of the EU's digital rulebook, it has already started in May with the deletion of a core compliance element in the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) - the obligation to keep records of your processing activities. While it sounds harmless - all the other rights and obligations still appy - it means that companies have no clue anymore what personal data they process, for which purposes, and how. A much larger revision has been proposed on 19th November 2025, with the "omnibus" legislation dubbed "Digital Simplification Package". This will affect rules on data protection, data governance, AI, obligations to report cybersecurity incidents, and protections against cookies and other tracking technologies. Furthermore, the EU's net neutrality rules are scheduled to be opened for reform in December by the so called Digital Networks Act. In this talk we discuss what to expect from the new EU agenda, who is driving it and how to resists. Our goal is to leave you better informed and equipped to fight back against this deregulatory trend. This talk may contain hope. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/throwing-your-rights-under-the-omnibus-how-the-eu-s-reform-agenda-threatens-to-erase-a-decade-of-digital-rights

Dec 27, 20251h 0m

Excuse me, what precise time is It? (39c3)

Dec 27, 202556 min

Not To Be Trusted - A Fiasco in Android TEEs (39c3)

Dec 27, 202549 min

Chatkontrolle (39c3)

Dec 27, 202555 min

BitUnlocker: Leveraging Windows Recovery to Extract BitLocker Secrets (39c3)

Dec 27, 202559 min

Landtagsrevue Live - AUA (Ask us Anything) (39c3)

Dec 27, 20251h 31m

Landtagsrevue Live - AUA (Ask us Anything) (39c3)

Live-Sonderausgabe der Landtagsrevue - dem Landespolitik-Ableger der Parlamentsrevue. Wir schauen zurück auf das erste Jahr der Landtagsrevue und beantworten eure Fragen rund um die Parlamente - wie funktioniert das eigentlich alles? Wo können wir als Zivilgesellschaft am besten Einfluss nehmen? Wer sind all diese Leute?? Schickt uns eure Fragen gern vorab an [email protected] - so können wir auch Antworten aus den Ländern mitbringen, die nicht live dabei sind. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/landtagsrevue-live

Dec 27, 20251h 31m

BitUnlocker: Leveraging Windows Recovery to Extract BitLocker Secrets (39c3)

This talk reveals our in-depth vulnerability research on the Windows Recovery Environment (WinRE) and its implications for BitLocker, Windows’ cornerstone for data protection. We will walk through the research methodology, uncover new 0-day vulnerabilities, and showcase full-chain exploitations that enabled us to bypass BitLocker and extract all the protected data in several different ways. This talk goes beyond theory - as each vulnerability will be accompanied by a demo video showcasing the complete exploitation chain. To conclude the talk, we will share Microsoft’s key takeaways from this research and outline our approach to hardening WinRE and BitLocker. In Windows, the cornerstone of data protection is BitLocker, a Full Volume Encryption technology designed to secure sensitive data on disk. This ensures that even if an adversary gains physical access to the device, the data remains secure and inaccessible. One of the most critical aspects of any data protection feature is its ability to support recovery operations in case of failure. To enable BitLocker recovery, significant design changes were implemented in the Windows Recovery Environment (WinRE). This led us to a pivotal question: did these changes introduce any new attack surfaces impacting BitLocker? In this talk, we will share our journey of researching a fascinating and mysterious component: WinRE. Our exploration begins with an overview of the WinRE architecture, followed by a retrospective analysis of the attack surfaces exposed with the introduction of BitLocker. We will then discuss our methodology for effectively researching and exploiting these exposed attack surfaces. Our presentation will reveal how we identified multiple 0-day vulnerabilities and developed fully functional exploits, enabling us to bypass BitLocker and extract all protected data in several different ways. Notably, the findings described reside entirely in the software stack, not requiring intrusive hardware attacks to be exploited. Finally, we will share the insights Microsoft gained from this research and explain our approach to hardening and further securing WinRE, which in turn strengthens BitLocker. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/bitunlocker-leveraging-windows-recovery-to-extract-bitlocker-secrets

Dec 27, 202559 min

Excuse me, what precise time is It? (39c3)

With PTP 1588, AES67, and SMPTE 2110, we can transmit synchronous audio and video with sub-millisecond latency over the asynchronous medium Ethernet. But how do you make hundreds of devices agree on the exact same nanosecond on a medium that was never meant to care about time? Precision Time Protocol (IEEE 1588) tries to do just that. It's the invisible backbone of realtime media standards like AES67 and SMPTE 2110, proprietary technologies such as Dante, and even critical systems powering high-frequency trading, cellular networks, and electric grids. Where even a few microseconds of drift can turn perfect sync into complete chaos. This talk takes a deep dive into the mysterious world of precise time distribution in large networks. We’ll start by exploring how PTP 1588 actually works, from announce, sync, and follow-up messages to delay measurements and the magic of hardware timestamping. We’ll look at why PTP is critical for modern audio/video-over-IP standards like AES67 and SMPTE 2110, and how they push Ethernet to its absolute temporal limits. Along the way, we’ll discover how transparent and boundary clocks fight jitter, and why your switch’s buffer might secretly hate you. We will do live Wireshark dissections of real PTP traffic, demos showing what happens when timing breaks, and some hands-on hardware experiments with grandmasters and followers trying to stay in sync. Expect packets, graphs, oscilloscopes, crashing live demos and at least one bad joke about time travel. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/excuse-me-what-precise-time-is-it

Dec 27, 202556 min

Not To Be Trusted - A Fiasco in Android TEEs (39c3)

Trusted Execution Environments (TEEs) based on ARM TrustZone form the backbone of modern Android devices' security architecture. The word "Trusted" in this context means that **you**, as in "the owner of the device", don't get to execute code in this execution environment. Even when you unlock the bootloader and Magisk-root your device, only vendor-signed code will be accepted by the TEE. This unfortunate setup limits third-party security research to the observation of input/output behavior and static manual reverse engineering of TEE components. In this talk, we take you with us on our journey to regain power over the highest privilege level on Xiaomi devices. Specifically, we are targeting the Xiaomi Redmi 11s and will walk through the steps necessary to escalate our privileges from a rooted user space (N-EL0) to the highest privilege level in the Secure World (S-EL3). We will revisit old friends like Trusted Application rollback attacks and GlobalPlatform's design flaw, and introduce novel findings like the literal fiasco you can achieve when you're introducing micro kernels without knowing what you're doing. In detail, we will elaborate on the precise exploitation steps taken and mitigations overcome at each stage of our exploit chain, and finally demo our exploits on stage. Regaining full control over our devices is the first step to deeply understand popular TEE-protected use cases including, but not limited to, mobile payment, mobile DRM solutions, and the mechanisms protecting your biometric authentication data. We present novel insights into the current state of TEE security on Android focusing on two widespread issues: missing TA rollback protection and a type confusion bug arising from the GlobalPlatform TEE Internal Core API specification. Our results demonstrate that these issues are so widespread that on most devices, attackers with code execution at N-EL1 (kernel) have a buffet of n-days to choose from to achieve code execution at S-EL0 (TA). Further, we demonstrate how these issues can be weaponized to fully compromise an Android device. We discuss how we exploit CVE-2023-32835, a type confusion bug in the keyinstall TA, on a fully updated Xiaomi Redmi Note 11. While the keyinstall TA shipped in the newest firmware version is not vulnerable anymore, the vulnerability remains triggerable due to missing rollback protections. To further demonstrate how powerful code execution as a TA is, we'll exploit a vulnerability in the BeanPod TEE (used on Xiaomi Mediatek SoCs), to achieve code execution at S-EL3. Full privilege escalations in the TEE are rarely seen on stage, and we are targeting the BeanPod TEE which is based on the Fiasco micro kernel. This target has never been publicly exploited, to the best of our knowledge. Our work empowers security researchers by demonstrating how to regain control over vendor-locked TEEs, enabling deeper analysis of critical security mechanisms like mobile payments, DRM, and biometric authentication. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/not-to-be-trusted-a-fiasco-in-android-tees

Dec 27, 202549 min

Chatkontrolle (39c3)

Seit jetzt schon vier Jahren droht aus der EU die Chatkontrolle. In Deutschland ist das Thema nach den Protesten im Oktober aktueller denn je - und sogar Jens Spahn und Rainer Wendt sind plötzlich gegen diese Form der Überwachung. In diesem Vortrag schauen wir zurück und erklären was, vor allem im Hintergrund, passiert ist. Wir nehmen die Position der Bundesregierung genau unter die Lupe und werfen einen Blick auf die Schritte, die auf EU-Ebene vor uns liegen. Die Chatkontrolle liest sich mehr wie eine tragische Komödie, als ein Gesetzgebungsverfahren. Nach dem dramaturgischen Rückblick auf dem 37C3 wird es nun Zeit einen Blick auf die Seite der Rebellen zu werfen. Markus Reuter und khaleesi haben den Gesetzgebungsprozess rund um die Chatkontrolle von Anfang an eng begleitet, er aus der der journalistischen, sie aus der Policy-Perspektive. Nach den ersten Jahren mit großen Rummel und Hollywoodstars ist es nach den EU-Wahlen doch etwas ruhig geworden. Doch die Gefahr ist nicht vom Tisch: Zwar steht die Position des EU-Parlaments gegen die Chatkontrolle - aber wie sicher sie wirklich ist, ist unklar. Derzeit hängt alles am Rat: Es gab sehr positive Vorschläge (polnische Ratspräsidentschaft) und negative Vorschläge (dänische Ratspräsidentschaft) - doch einigen können sich die Länder nicht und eine Mehrheit will die Chatkontrolle, kann sich aber nicht durchsetzen. Und auch in Deutschland hat die Chatkontrolle den ganz großen Sprung in die Öffentlichkeit geschafft und die Gegner:innen einen Etappensieg errungen. Was dieser Erfolg mit der Arbeit der letzten vier Jahre zu tun hat und warum auch in Deutschland noch nichts in trockenen Tüchern ist, erzählen wir in diesem Talk. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/episode-ii-der-rat-schlagt-zuruck

Dec 27, 202555 min

Life on Hold: What Does True Solidarity Look Like Beyond Duldung, Camps, Deportation, and Payment Cards? (39c3)

Lager, Duldung, Bezahlkarte, Essensscheine – Criminalization, Radicalization, Reality for Many People in East Germany This talk sheds light on how these terms shape everyday life. We dive into an existence marked by uncertainty, isolation, and psychological strain, both in anonymous big cities and rural areas of East Germany. We ask: What does “solidarity” really mean in this context? In this session, people share everyday experiences with a system that often systematically undermines human rights and dignity. We don’t just talk about the obvious obstacles like the payment card or residency obligation, but also the invisible wounds: the constant fear of deportation, the psychological consequences of isolation, and the daily experience of hostility. We highlight the specific challenges of life in cramped camps on the outskirts of big cities, as well as the social control and visibility in rural communities. However, this talk is not just about naming problems. At its core is the urgent question: What does true solidarity really look like? How can support go beyond symbolic politics and short-term aid offers? This session is an invitation to shift perspectives, listen, and collaboratively develop concrete approaches for a more humane policy and a more solidaric coexistence. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/life-on-hold-what-does-true-solidarity-look-like-beyond-duldung-camps-deportation-and-payment-cards

Dec 27, 20251h 0m

Die Känguru-Rebellion: Digital Independence Day (39c3)

Marc-Uwe Kling liest neues vom Känguru vor. Vielleicht auch was von Elon und Jeff on Mars. Und dann ruft das Känguru zum Digital Independence Day auf. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/die-kanguru-rebellion-digital-independence-day

Dec 27, 202556 min

And so it begins - Wie unser Rechtsstaat auf dem Highway Richtung Trumpismus rast – und warum afghanische Kläger*innen für uns die Notbremse ziehen (39c3)

Wenn die Regierung sich nicht mehr an das eigene Recht gebunden fühlt, markiert das nicht nur einen politischen Spurwechsel, sondern die Auffahrt auf den Highway to Trumpism. Zeit die Notbremse zu ziehen! Normalerweise trifft es in solchen Situationen immer zuerst diejenigen, die sich am wenigsten wehren können. Doch was passiert, wenn genau diese Menschen mit juristischen Werkzeugen bewaffnet werden, um zurückzuschlagen? Anhand von über 100 Klagen afghanischer Schutzsuchender zeigen wir, wie Ministerien das Bundesaufnahmeprogramm sabotieren, Gerichte sie zurückpfeifen – und die Zivilgesellschaft zum letzten Schutzwall des Rechtsstaats wird. Und wir verraten, warum sich Beamte im BAMF vielleicht lieber krankmelden sollten und welche anderen Möglichkeiten sie haben, um nicht straffällig zu werden. • Versprochen ist versprochen und wird auch nicht gebrochen“ – das lernen wir schon als Kinder. Aber der Kindergarten ist schon lange her, und Politiker*innen haben zwar oft das Auftreten eines Elefanten, aber das Gedächtnis eines Goldfischs. • Deswegen hätte die Bundesregierung auch fast 2.500 Afghan*innen mit deutschen Aufnahmezusagen in Islamabad „vergessen“, die dort seit Monaten auf die Ausstellung ihrer deutschen Visa warten • Das Kalkül dahinter: Pakistan erledigt die Drecksarbeit und schiebt sie früher oder später ab, Problem solved! - selbst wenn dabei Menschenleben auf dem Spiel stehen. • Wie kann die Zivilgesellschaft die Notbremse ziehen, wenn sich Regierung und Verwaltung nicht mehr an das eigene Recht gebunden fühlen? • Eine Möglichkeit: wir vernetzen die afghanischen Familien mit Anwält*innen, damit sie Dobrindt und Wadephul verklagen - und sie gewinnen! Die Gerichtsbeschlüsse sind eindeutig: Visa sofort erteilen – sonst Strafzahlungen! Inzwischen laufen über 100 Verfahren an vier Verwaltungsgerichten, weitere kommen täglich hinzu. • Das dürfte nicht ganz das gewesen sein, was die neue Bundesregierung meinte, als sie im Koalitionsvertrag verkündete, „freiwillige Aufnahmeprogramme so weit wie möglich zu beenden“. Übersetzung der politischen Realitätsversion: Wenn es nach Dobrindt und dem Kanzler geht, sollen möglichst gar keine Schutzsuchenden aus Afghanistan mehr nach Deutschland kommen – rechtsverbindliche Aufnahmezusagen hin oder her. Einreisen dürfen nur noch anerkannte Terroristen aus der Taliban-Regierung, um hier in Deutschland die afghanischen Botschaften und Konsulate zu übernehmen • Durch die Klagen konnten bereits 78 Menschen einreisen, etwa 80 weitere Visa sind in Bearbeitung – und weitere werden vorbereitet. • Doch wie in jedem Drehbuch gilt: The Empire strikes back! Die Regierung entwickelt laufend neue Methoden, um Urteile ins Leere laufen zu lassen und Einreisen weiterhin zu blockieren. • Willkommen im „Trumpismus made in Germany“. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/and-so-it-begins-wie-unser-rechtsstaat-auf-den-highway-richtung-trumpismus-rast-und-warum-afghanische-klager-innen-fur-uns-die-notbremse-ziehen

Dec 27, 202549 min

Die Känguru-Rebellion: Digital Independence Day (39c3)

Dec 27, 202556 min

Die Sicherheits_lücke live vom 39c3: ein Tag mit der GI (39c3)

Dec 27, 202542 min

And so it begins - Wie unser Rechtsstaat auf dem Highway Richtung Trumpismus rast – und warum afghanische Kläger*innen für uns die Notbremse ziehen (39c3)

Dec 27, 202549 min

1965 + 60 Years of Algorithmic Art with Computers (39c3)

Dec 27, 202550 min

Life on Hold: What Does True Solidarity Look Like Beyond Duldung, Camps, Deportation, and Payment Cards? (39c3)

Dec 27, 20251h 0m

1965 + 60 Years of Algorithmic Art with Computers (39c3)

What power structures are inherent to the field of computer-generated art? In the year 1965, so 60 years ago, the first three exhibitions of art created with the help of computers took place - in part independently of each other. We want to present the interesting aspects of developments since then and discuss them with Frieder Nake, one of the people who exhibited in those very beginnings and followed those developments with a critical attitude. We want to look at the complex topic of art created with computers, beginning with some careful and barely noticed first experiments and emerging into an ever more diverse and creative field, from different angles. In particular, we want to focus on the dynamics of power and how these developments were influenced by their context - from social movements to political pressure. We want to start with explaining how the initial developments, both from an artistic - concrete art - and technological - the evolution of computers and the creation of the drawing machine Zuse Z64 in Germany and film techniques in the US, respectively - took place. We will do so in the context of the first three exhibitions that all took place in the year 1965. Their artworks were created by Georg Nees in Stuttgart, A. Michael Noll with Béla Julesz in New York and Frieder Nake with Georg Nees, again in Stuttgart. In the following, we will try to give an outline of further developments. We provide examples how hierachies in art and science have developed and played a role in different events. In the domain of computer-generated art, similar to other art, there are two large influences hidden for the typical recipent of this art - galleries and critics. We will discuss this exemplary with early exhibitions of Frieder Nake being described by the FAZ and later on, how the east-west conflict has influenced the art and its exhibitions. Among other issues, we discuss patriarchal structures, the commercial side of art, how old tech is sold as revolutionary and how progress is still as connected with threatening feelings as in the early years. Looking back at the beginnings, it is interesting to observe how artists - also with an artistic, rather than technical background - worked with the limitations and overcame them. Fortunately, the technological entry barrier to create algorithmic art yourself has drastically decreased over time and we want to encourage you to experiment yourself! Frieder Nake is creating algorithmic drawings and doing visual research since 1964. In 1971, he published the influential essay "there should be no computer art" and he has been teaching computer graphics at the University of Bremen for decades. Enna Gerhard is pursuing a PhD in theory of computer science and creates algorithmic drawings in the meantime. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/1965-60-years-of-algorithmic-art-with-computers

Dec 27, 202550 min

Die Sicherheits_lücke live vom 39c3: ein Tag mit der GI (39c3)

Die **Sicherheits_lücke** (https://sicherheitsluecke.fm) greift aktuelle Ereignisse und Trends der Cybersecurity auf. Im Podcast werden die Themen - gerne auch mal humoristisch, sarkastisch oder selbstironisch - von Volker Skwarek, Monina Schwarz und Ingo Timm mit Tiefgang aufbereitet. Mit dem Format **live** ist der Podcast auch regelmäßig auf Kongressen zu finden und diskutiert interessante Vorträge mit ausgewählten Gästen. Wir berichten mit Gästinnen von der Gesellschaft für Informatik über interessante Vorträge und Erlebnisse vom ersten Tag des 39c3. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/die-sicherheits_lucke-live-vom-39c3-ein-tag-mit-de

Dec 27, 202542 min

Eine typisch österreichische Lösung - die Dirndlkoalition (39c3)

Dec 27, 202545 min

Eine typisch österreichische Lösung - die Dirndlkoalition (39c3)

Nach den längsten Koalitionsverhandlungen in der zweiten Republik kämpft die Dirndlkoalition gegen Inflation, Budgetdefizit und rechte Volkskanzlerfantasien. Wir geben einen Überblick zum politischen Jahr in Österreich. Am Beginn des Jahres wollte Herbert Kickl noch Volkskanzler werden, am Ende des Jahres regiert eine Dreierkoalition in Österreich. Wie gewohnt wollen wir auch heuer wieder erzählen, was in der österreichischen Innenpolitik passiert, der Humor soll dabei nicht zu kurz kommen. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/eine-typisch-sterreichische-lsung-die-dirndlkoalition

Dec 27, 202545 min

Syncing visuals and stage lights against the beat of live music: an introduction (39c3)

Most clubs and concerts have predefined light and visuals, and often they are generic and not synced to the beat of the music. Today we will show you that it's actually possible to sync visual effects to the beat of live music recorded from the microphone, and it's pretty easy! Aimed at beginners. We will teach people how to set up and use TouchDesigner to perform audio analysis and how to draw basic effects and light shows that respond to the beat of the input audio. If you want to follow along, please come with TouchDesigner preinstalled (the free version is perfectly fine). Recommended on Windows or Mac, but with enough pain it can run under Wine as well. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/syncing-visuals-and-stage-lights-against-the-beat-

Dec 27, 202530 min

Syncing visuals and stage lights against the beat of live music: an introduction (39c3)

Dec 27, 202530 min

Handy weg bis zur Ausreise (39c3)

Seit Anfang 2024 dürfen Ausländerbehörden Smartphones von ausreisepflichtigen Menschen nicht nur durchsuchen, sondern gleich ganz behalten – „bis zur Ausreise“. Was als geringfügige Änderung im Aufenthaltsgesetz daherkommt, erweist sich als massiver Eingriff in Grundrechte: Menschen verlieren nicht nur die Kontrolle über ihre Daten, sondern auch ihr wichtigstes Kommunikationsmittel – auf unbestimmte Zeit. Hier hört ihr, welche absurden Blüten das treibt. Von Bayern bis NRW haben Bundesländer inzwischen eigene IT-forensische Tools für ihre Behörden angeschafft, um auf den Geräten nach “Indizien” für die Herkunft zu suchen. Sie setzen Methoden ein, wie wir sie sonst aus Ermittlungsverfahren oder von Geheimdiensten kennen – um die Geräte von Menschen zu durchsuchen, die nichts verbrochen haben. Seit Anfang 2024 dürfen Ausländerbehörden Smartphones von ausreisepflichtigen Menschen nicht nur durchsuchen, sondern gleich ganz behalten – „bis zur Ausreise“. Was als geringfügige Änderung im Aufenthaltsgesetz daherkommt, erweist sich als massiver Eingriff in Grundrechte: Menschen verlieren nicht nur die Kontrolle über ihre Daten, sondern auch ihr wichtigstes Kommunikationsmittel – auf unbestimmte Zeit. Hier hört ihr, welche absurden Blüten das treibt. Von Bayern bis NRW haben Bundesländer inzwischen eigene IT-forensische Tools für ihre Behörden angeschafft, um auf den Geräten nach “Indizien” für die Herkunft zu suchen. Sie setzen Methoden ein, wie wir sie sonst aus Ermittlungsverfahren oder von Geheimdiensten kennen – um die Geräte von Menschen zu durchsuchen, die nichts verbrochen haben. Im Vortrag zeige ich, welche absurden Konsequenzen das für die Betroffenen mit sich bringt, welche Bundesländer an der traurigen Spitze der Statistik stehen – und wie sich das Ganze in das Arsenal der digitalen und sonstigen Repressionen von Geflüchteten einreiht. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/handy-weg-bis-zur-ausreise-wie-cellebrite-ins-auslanderamt-kam

Dec 27, 20251h 1m

To sign or not to sign: Practical vulnerabilities in GPG & friends (39c3)

Dec 27, 202548 min

Handy weg bis zur Ausreise (39c3)

Dec 27, 20251h 1m

Och Menno – IT und IT Security Uppsis (39c3)

Dec 27, 202542 min

Pwn2Roll: Who Needs a 595€ Remote When You Have wheelchair.py? (39c3)

Dec 27, 202556 min

Escaping Containment: A Security Analysis of FreeBSD Jails (39c3)

Dec 27, 202559 min

Pwn2Roll: Who Needs a 595€ Remote When You Have wheelchair.py? (39c3)

A 595€ wheelchair remote that sends a handful of Bluetooth commands. A 99.99€ app feature that does exactly what the 595€ hardware does. A speed upgrade from 6 to 8.5 km/h locked behind a 99.99€ paywall - because apparently catching the bus is a premium feature. Welcome to the wonderful world of DRM in assistive devices, where already expensive basic mobility costs extra and comes with in-app purchases! And because hackers gonna hack, this just could not be left alone. This talk depicts the reverse engineering of a popular electric wheelchair drive system - the Alber e-motion M25: a several thousand euro assistive device that treats mobility like a SaaS subscription. Through Android app reverse engineering, proprietary Bluetooth protocol analysis, hours of staring at hex dumps (instead of the void), and good old-fashioned packet sniffing, we'll expose how manufacturers artificially limit essential features and monetize basic human mobility. What you'll learn: - how a 22-character QR code sticker, labeled as "Cyber Security Key", becomes AES encryption - why your 6000€ wheelchair drive includes an app with Google Play Billing integration for features the hardware already supports - the internals, possibilities and features of electronics worth 30€ cosplaying as a 595€ medical device - the technical implementation of the "pay 99.99€ or stay slow" speed limiter (6 km/h vs 8.5 km/h) - how nearly 2000€ in hardware and app features can be replaced by a few hundred lines of Python - why the 8000€ even more premium (self-driving) variant is literally identical hardware with a different Boolean flag and firmware plus another (pricier) remote We'll cover the complete methodology: from initial reconnaissance, sniffing and decrypting packets to reverse-engineer the proprietary communication protocol, to PoCs of Python replacements, tools, techniques, and ethical considerations of reverse engineering medical devices. This is a story about artificial scarcity, exploitative DRM, ethics and industry power, and how hacker-minded creatures should react and act to this. This talk will be simultaneously interpretated into German sign language (Deutsche Gebärdensprache aka. DGS). Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/pwn2roll-who-needs-a-599-remote-when-you-have-wheelchair-py

Dec 27, 202556 min

Escaping Containment: A Security Analysis of FreeBSD Jails (39c3)

FreeBSD’s jail mechanism promises strong isolation—but how strong is it really? In this talk, we explore what it takes to escape a compromised FreeBSD jail by auditing the kernel’s attack surface, identifying dozens of vulnerabilities across exposed subsystems, and developing practical proof-of-concept exploits. We’ll share our findings, demo some real escapes, and discuss what they reveal about the challenges of maintaining robust OS isolation. FreeBSD’s jail feature is one of the oldest and most mature OS-level isolation mechanisms in use today, powering hosting environments, container frameworks, and security sandboxes. But as with any large and evolving kernel feature, complexity breeds opportunity. This research asks a simple but critical question: If an attacker compromises root inside a FreeBSD jail, what does it take to break out? To answer that, we conducted a large-scale audit of FreeBSD kernel code paths accessible from within a jail. We systematically examined privileged operations, capabilities, and interfaces that a jailed process can still reach, hunting for memory safety issues, race conditions, and logic flaws. The result: roughly 50 distinct issues uncovered across multiple kernel subsystems, ranging from buffer overflows and information leaks to unbounded allocations and reference counting errors—many of which could crash the system or provide vectors for privilege escalation beyond the jail. We’ve developed proof-of-concept exploits and tools to demonstrate some of these vulnerabilities in action. We’ve responsibly disclosed our findings to the FreeBSD security team and are collaborating with them on fixes. Our goal isn’t to break FreeBSD, but to highlight the systemic difficulty of maintaining strict isolation in a large, mature codebase. This talk will present our methodology, tooling, and selected demos of real jail escapes. We’ll close with observations about kernel isolation boundaries, lessons learned for other OS container systems, and a call to action for hardening FreeBSD’s jail subsystem against the next generation of threats. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/escaping-containment-a-security-analysis-of-freebsd-jails

Dec 27, 202559 min

To sign or not to sign: Practical vulnerabilities in GPG & friends (39c3)

Might contain zerodays. https://gpg.fail/ From secure communications to software updates: PGP implementations such as *GnuPG* ubiquitously relied on to provide cryptographic assurances. Many applications from secure communications to software updates fundamentally rely on these utilities. Since these have been developed for decades, one might expect mature codebases, a multitude of code audit reports, and extensive continuous testing. When looking into various PGP-related codebases for some personal use cases, we found these expectations not met, and discovered multiple vulnerabilities in cryptographic utilities, namely in *GnuPG*, *Sequoia PGP*, *age*, and *minisign*. The vulnerabilities have implementation bugs at their core, for example in parsing code, rather than bugs in the mathematics of the cryptography itself. A vulnerability in a parser could for example lead to a confusion about what data was actually signed, allowing attackers without the private key of the signer to swap the plain text. As we initially did not start with the intent of conducting security research, but rather were looking into understanding some internals of key management and signatures for personal use, we also discuss the process of uncovering these bugs. Furthermore, we touch on the role of the OpenPGP specification, and the disclosure process. Beyond the underlying mathematics of cryptographic algorithms, there is a whole other layer of implementation code, assigning meaning to the processed data. For example, a signature verification operation both needs robust cryptography **and** assurance that the verified data is indeed the same as was passed into the signing operation. To facilitate the second part, software such as *GnuPG* implement parsing and processing code of a standardized format. Especially when implementing a feature rich and evolving standard, there is the risk of ambivalent specification, and classical implementation bugs. The impact of the vulnerabilities we found reaches from various signature verification bypasses, breaking encryption in transit and encryption at rest, undermining key signatures, to exploitable memory corruption vulnerabilities. Licensed to the public under http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0 about this event: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/event/detail/to-sign-or-not-to-sign-practical-vulnerabilities-i

Dec 27, 202548 min