Andy Martino Talks Secret To Breaking Stories Like Pete Alonso and Juan Soto Signings

Andy Martino joins Jay Horwitz for a special episode of Amazin’ Conversations to talk about what it really takes to break news in Major League Baseball. From cultivating authentic human relationships with players like Juan Soto and executives across front offices, to his journey from the Daily News to SNY insider coverage of the Mets and Yankees, Andy shares candid stories, media insights, and reflections on the evolution of baseball journalism.

They dive into behind-the-scenes moments, including his connection to Shannon Forde’s legacy, covering David Wright’s career, and how Carlos Beltrán is helping shape today’s Mets. If you’ve ever wondered how the biggest Mets scoops get reported — this one’s for you.

🧠 Featuring insider takes on:

• Breaking the Pete Alonso story
• Balancing trust and reporting in the clubhouse
• Why Carlos Beltrán is the most underrated Met ever

📍Don’t forget to like, subscribe, and drop a comment on your favorite Mets moment.

#Mets #AndyMartino #MLBInsider #PeteAlonso #CarlosBeltran #CitiField #Yankees #MLBNews #JayHorwitz #BaseballMedia #MeetAtTheApple

⏱️ YouTube Timestamps (Chapters):

00:00 – Andy Martino on authentic relationships in baseball

01:01 – Why news isn’t always the priority

02:06 – Remembering Shannon Forde and Foley’s memories

03:16 – The human side of journalism

04:02 – Covering both Mets and Yankees: why just two teams

05:01 – Andy’s start at the Daily News & media evolution

06:12 – Leaving print for broadcast: SNY’s vision and Fred Wilpon’s role

07:20 – Breaking the Alonso signing and the job of being first

08:01 – Round-the-clock grind of MLB insider life

09:26 – Why focusing on Mets & Yankees keeps it manageable

10:05 – Martino’s mindset: don’t just be a news extractor

11:12 – Learning baseball from the players themselves

12:16 – Handling criticism & social media toxicity

13:10 – Interacting with Mets fans IRL vs online

13:34 – The collaborative joy of working in TV vs print

14:27 – Why writing is still his true passion

14:55 – How he got Brian Cashman to trust him for his book

16:05 – Unsung Yankees contributors recognized in the book

17:00 – On fair reporting and trust with PR staffs

18:15 – News is just a byproduct of relationships

19:00 – On competitive sourcing & beat reporting

20:15 – Terry Collins and the value of honest communication

20:37 – Carlos Beltrán's underappreciated Mets legacy

21:39 – How Beltrán is mentoring Lindor behind the scenes

22:54 – Watching David Wright evolve through his career

24:06 – A David Wright story that defines his character

25:06 – Why Martino still finds joy in his job

26:05 – Jay Horwitz gets his flowers from Martino

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices