AIPT's comics & geeky gifts holiday buyer’s guide
Looking to treat yourself (or your favorite nerd) before the year wraps? We’ve put together a no-nonsense, highly clickable guide to the best comics, collectibles, and experiences you can buy right now or preorder for 2025. Every pick below is either already out in 2025 or available to lock in this year, so you won’t be chasing ghosts—or last year’s stock. We’ve split our recommendations into eight easy buckets—from Smart Buys that stretch your dollar (think chunky omnibuses and killer subs) to Shelf Candy that looks unreal on display, Hype Picks everyone’s buzzing about, and even a Rich Friend Buy for when money’s no object. You’ll also find deep-cut grails for collectors, interactive Experience Buys that deliver hours of engagement, perfect gifts for civilians, and a Wild Card section for the gloriously weird.
Audio is streamed directly from the publisher (cdn.simplecast.com) as published in their RSS feed. Play Podcasts does not host this file. Rights-holders can request removal through the copyright & takedown page.
Show Notes
1. 🧠 The Smart Buy (Best Value for Money)
Items that deliver the most substance for their cost — thick trades, box sets, digital bundles, or multi-use gear. (Example: an Omnibus Edition, Marvel Unlimited, or a good pair of Bluetooth headphones for audiobook listening.)
Dave:
- The Transformers Compendium Vol. 1 (Order here: $38 on Amazon for 44 issues!)
- Superman: The Golden Age Omnibus Vol. 1 (Order here: 2025 Edition)
Alex:
- Marvel Unlimited ($69/year) & DC Universe ($74.99)
- X-Men Fatal Attractions Omnibus (Order here: 47% off on Amazon!)
2. 🖼️ Shelf Candy (Best Display or Design Piece)
Books, collectibles, or art prints that look incredible on a shelf. Could include deluxe hardcovers, vinyl soundtracks, statues, or even minimalist poster series.
Dave:
- The Fantastic Four: First Steps Poster (more info)
- McFarlane Toys - Marvel Venom 1:6th Scale Collectible with Scene & Comic (Order here: more info)
Alex:
- Jumbo Size Funko Superman
- Mondo X-Men ‘97 Storm Figure
3. 💥 The Hype Pick (What Everyone’s Talking About)
This year’s buzziest thing — a trending comic, toy line, show, or crossover event. Great for conversation starters and “must-have” energy.
Dave: All the Absolute comics! Absolute Batman (link), Absolute Wonder Woman (link), Absolute Superman (link), Absolute Martian Manhunter (link), Absolute Green Lantern (link).
Alex: Ultimate Universe Box Set: 1,000 pages, $84.99, from a cover price of $120. (Order here: Discounted on Amazon)
4. 🕹️ The Experience Buy (Immersive or Interactive Purchases)
Games, tabletop sets, or hobby kits that offer hours of engagement. Could include LEGO kits, or VR titles — anything that rewards time spent.
Dave:
Alex:
- Tickets to Emerald City Comic Con
- Rolife book nooks
5. 🎁 The Perfect Gift (Universal Crowd-Pleasers)
Accessible, fun items that make ideal gifts for fans or newcomers alike — art books, indie trades, collectible card sets, or streaming subscriptions.
Dave:
- JLA Earth 2 Deluxe Edition (more info)
- Alex Ross Marvel Super Villains Mural 2025 Oversized Wall Calendar (more info)
Alex: Absolute Wonder Woman Vol. 1, gift card to MyComicShop.com
6. 🔥 The Deep Cut (For Hardcore Collectors)
Rare editions, imports, signed items, or niche merchandise that appeals to completists and superfans.
Dave: Jim Aparo's DC Classics Artist's Edition (or any Artist’s Edition for that matter!)
Alex: Taschen X-Men edition (more info)
7. 🎧 The Rich Friend Buy (Stuff That Most Can’t Afford)
Nuff said.
Dave: Wolverine: Weapon X statue (more info), or if you really wanna splurge.
Alex: X-Men Danger Room and all Stephen King Marvel Omnibus collected.
8. 🌀 The Wild Card
Anything offbeat, surprising, or delightfully weird — a novelty figure, indie zine, retro collectible, or something you didn’t expect to love but now can’t stop recommending.
Dave: The End Times (Info here) and PeePee PooPoo #100,000 (more info)
Alex: Any comic from Silver Sprocket, like Of Thunder & Lightning and the Chromatic Fantasy, also, just go to your LCS and look for vintage figures!
And that's a wrap on our gift guide. We hope you enjoy the podcast explanations for why we picked them, and we'll be back on our regular scheduled weekly basis a week after next!